for Second Chances6/5/2008 c4 
2A Bibliophile
I am loving this story. I like both Wicked and HP, an this is the first crossover I've seen of the rwo
2A BibliophileI am loving this story. I like both Wicked and HP, an this is the first crossover I've seen of the rwo
6/4/2008 c3 A Bibliophile
I wan't Elphy to do something! Or tell someone! or have Glinda show up! Or Phiero!
I wan't Elphy to do something! Or tell someone! or have Glinda show up! Or Phiero!
6/4/2008 c2 A Bibliophile
I can't wait to see her views on Harry. Will her being Elphy end up changing the timeline?
I can't wait to see her views on Harry. Will her being Elphy end up changing the timeline?
9/28/2007 c9 AJK200001
I LOVED THIS STORY! I wish you would make a sequel. I can easily see Elphie as Professor McGonagall. I think its cool that Glinda was in the story too. I hope you do write a sequel one day.
I LOVED THIS STORY! I wish you would make a sequel. I can easily see Elphie as Professor McGonagall. I think its cool that Glinda was in the story too. I hope you do write a sequel one day.
8/6/2007 c9 7Aurinko
Wonderful! I've yet to see Wicked, but my best friend loves it and this fic is great. It's not an idea I've ever considered, but you weave the two very well together. And I'm glad that they've finally gotten together, too. Please continue soon!
7AurinkoWonderful! I've yet to see Wicked, but my best friend loves it and this fic is great. It's not an idea I've ever considered, but you weave the two very well together. And I'm glad that they've finally gotten together, too. Please continue soon!
7/5/2007 c9 the music lady
incredible. you are perhaps the most original crossoverist (yes it is Too a word!) EVER!
awesome possum.
incredible. you are perhaps the most original crossoverist (yes it is Too a word!) EVER!
awesome possum.
6/26/2007 c9 9moon eclipse shadows
I have never seen or read Wicked. But I decided to take a chance at this because I could always stop reading it, and because I enjoy so many of your stories. I'm really glad I did. This is an amazing story. I wonder again why I didn't have you on author alerts. Well, that's about to be changed. ~^.^~
Again, it was an AMAZINGLY WONDERFUL story.
9moon eclipse shadowsI have never seen or read Wicked. But I decided to take a chance at this because I could always stop reading it, and because I enjoy so many of your stories. I'm really glad I did. This is an amazing story. I wonder again why I didn't have you on author alerts. Well, that's about to be changed. ~^.^~
Again, it was an AMAZINGLY WONDERFUL story.
6/20/2007 c9 3LoonyXBirdX
I usually don't read cross overs. I think they're just pointless, and stupid, but this one was really good. And you wrote it so well. I loved it!
3LoonyXBirdXI usually don't read cross overs. I think they're just pointless, and stupid, but this one was really good. And you wrote it so well. I loved it!
6/19/2007 c9 38MarbleGlove
This is a truly fabulous story. Thank you for posting it. I really, really liked Minerva's confrontation with Voldemort: "I never claimed to a be a Light Witch." Wonderful.
38MarbleGloveThis is a truly fabulous story. Thank you for posting it. I really, really liked Minerva's confrontation with Voldemort: "I never claimed to a be a Light Witch." Wonderful.
6/15/2007 c9 61AssortedScribbler
I'm practically speechless, so this review may take a while to write. This is definitely one of the most Phenominally Fantastic and Amazing fic I have ever and will ever read. Your use of language never ceases to amaze me, and I just loved her answer: “I…I believe that I may be in love with you as well, Albus.” It was so Minerva and Elphaba at the same time! You have completely convinced me that Minerva is Elphaba and your story has just entranced me from the very first word to the last. I cannot tell you how wonerful I think this story is with my limited vocabulary, I woudl praise you every language is I was able. It is just magical (forgive the pun) and I hope you write another very soon. I wish you the best of luck, and thank you so much for posting this, and for the MMAD at the end, it just perfected everything.
xxStellaxx
61AssortedScribblerI'm practically speechless, so this review may take a while to write. This is definitely one of the most Phenominally Fantastic and Amazing fic I have ever and will ever read. Your use of language never ceases to amaze me, and I just loved her answer: “I…I believe that I may be in love with you as well, Albus.” It was so Minerva and Elphaba at the same time! You have completely convinced me that Minerva is Elphaba and your story has just entranced me from the very first word to the last. I cannot tell you how wonerful I think this story is with my limited vocabulary, I woudl praise you every language is I was able. It is just magical (forgive the pun) and I hope you write another very soon. I wish you the best of luck, and thank you so much for posting this, and for the MMAD at the end, it just perfected everything.
xxStellaxx
6/11/2007 c9 Aleta II Anon
Yay! I love this story so very much and it was a very satisfying ending. I look forward to reading more from you and would love a possible sequel. Brilliant job again.
Yay! I love this story so very much and it was a very satisfying ending. I look forward to reading more from you and would love a possible sequel. Brilliant job again.