FanFiction | Just In Community Forum | More
V
More
for Clash

1/3/2011 c18 Tessi
What? No Zutara ending?
6/27/2010 c18 Ariadne
WTF! Thanks Heaven, i didn't read it yet! But thanks for you, i've lost five minutes of my life, copying this stuff! It may surprise you, but some people use the search by the reason. If i see ZUTARA, i wish to read ZUTARA, nothing else.

You could be a great author, and your story could be the best, but i really will be very disappointed, if i's read it and see something unleasant at the end as Aang. Just change the pairing or write a little note, if the main pairing fix your story.
3/14/2009 c18 2Nicole'KA
YAY! omg, the way you write, it's makes me cry. You really get the emotions in here.. And when Katara choose Aang... I felt so happy xp ( I'm a Kataanger, soo of course I'm happy ) But.. If I read a Zutarafic then I normally gets angry, 'cause I don't feel they get their charathers right. But this didn't make me angry. It's very beautiful, that you can think about how Katara is confused about this. - I mean.. In the real seasons nothing like this happened ( okay - maybe something with EIP, but it's not the same.)

I really love your story. :)
1/3/2009 c18 5Dark Neko 4000
u just messed up da story by stating that it is a zutara story and it isn't
10/24/2008 c19 7arizony
Thank you for your marvelous story. So many of the Zutara fics out there are, as you said, so very superficial. Yours is wonderful because it does go into detail about Katara's emotions. It also has Zuko's true feelings, that it is more important that Katara and Aang are together than he and Katara fulfill their superficial lust for one another. Yes, Zuko, after starting with lust, finds that Katara is someone he can love. But, something that all the other Zutara fics miss is Zuko's sense of honor. To someone like Zuko, that is more important than life itself. He also sees that it is more important that he not betray someone who has accepted him as a friend (Aang). Very good story.
8/29/2008 c19 5timisnotmyname
yeah, im almost didn;t read this story...

but i kept seeing it in the favs of die-hard Kataangers...

even still, i thought it would be Zutara at the end, but way to turn it around! Kataang rules!

And now im in the know 2! ! ! ! ! ;)
5/1/2008 c19 Arika
hello, ok review done.

lolz

i really liked it. i read the whole thing. it was wonderful...but it made me think...calm down this isnt real avatar..lol.

i m a zutara fan...yup.

but i dont like how the characteristics of zuko, aang and even katara are changed.

but i guess u had to cuz zuko would never do that.

howcome whenever zuko and katara meet under the tree all they do is kiss each other...like everyday.
1/4/2008 c19 8thesimplyuninspired
Hello, and salutations to you. I have been holding off on reviewing for a few days now (due more to my own procrastinating nature than anything,) and even now I'm still floundering for the words. But I'll do my best to tell you my opinion, so please, just bear with me.

When first coming across this fic, I tried to sit down to it, tried to keep in mind that it was *Zutaraang*, not Zutara, but unfortunately became one of those mentioned in your notes at the end, who thought "Oh great, just another Zutara!" and gave up when finishing the most recent chapter up at that time: "Katara?"

After that, I continued looking around and, despite my thoughts picking at it from time to time, eventually sort of forgot about this; then (I can't really remember now why or when,) I spotted it again. Giving in to curiosity, I decided to have another go.

And I am so very glad I did.

I must extend my apologies; I judged this fic prematurely, and I shouldn't have. Instead of some overly cliche piece of fanon, this fic proved to be a well thought-out, deep, gorgeously written piece of art. Even though I was positively overjoyed with the end result, I wouldn't have completely disagreed with a Zutara ending. With every chapter in this fic, it's obvious that you put time and effort into each one, into Katara’s thoughts and feelings and each decision she made about Aang and Zuko, and that - I find that to be a rarity in fanfiction.

When I found opinions of my own addressed in here, I was further intrigued: I found it very interesting indeed to find I wasn’t alone in these thoughts. One major example: Love vs Lust. In every piece of fanart that made me feel something, every theory I’ve seen, it has always fallen with me that Zutara was more about lust and Kataang more about love. That’s one of the reasons I really don’t like Zutara: there’s nothing to suggest they’d ever love each other (even though I am completely aware that love is a force all its own and anything is possible; Zutara is just highly improbable to me.) Not in the way of totally epic love I’ve seen between Aang and Katara, anyway.

I do have one complaint: I feel Zuko is a tad out of character. Around adults, he’s more in control of himself, more assertive; but place him among his peers, and he clams up. He’s pretty shy (yes, I said shy) around his own age group, especially ones he likes/wants to like him. (That’s the kicker right there: I think that if he wanted Katara to like him, he’d be less forward with her, like he was with Jin. With Mai, he already knew how he felt about her, and how she felt about him, so he was a little more comfortable around her and trying less to impress – when they were alone, of course. I guess they both have some ways to go as far as PDA is concerned.) The only experience he had interacting with his own age group growing up was Azula, Ty Lee, and Mai, and that probably speaks for itself. But, with the whole angle of Love vs Lust, you went pretty in character. It’s just a pet-peeve of mine. (And we don’t really know how the two will act around each other anyway, do we?)

Well, this has been a pretty lengthy review, and I don’t think I really got across how quite lovely I found the whole thing. I mean, when Aang walks in on Katara and Zuko, I could feel my heart breaking for him – but I was also feeling for Katara. In the same moment I wanted to strangle her for being so stupid, yet hug her or something, try to comfort her. That is something which is pretty difficult to pull off, and I think you did it marvelously. The imagery, the emotion, the interactions- all were well-written and not just slapped in to impress. I didn’t think it was dragged out (I will admit, I was on the edge of my seat,) though I did want to slap Katara from time to time.

Again, I want to apologize for my lack of patience at first; this is a good read (as far as emotional rollercoaster-rides are concerned,) and it really captured my heart. Congrats on finishing such a beautiful ficcie; it’s well worth rereading a couple-dozen times or more.
12/31/2007 c18 6Lily Dragon
Ooh... So cute, so sad, so beautiful...

I simply loved your fic! But... Is it over? *snifs*

I wonder if Aang wouldn't still be hurt by Katara being with Zuko... Would he really accept her back so easily?

Naah, but that's just speculation.

Poor Zuko... He does really deserve her in his "new state"...

I hope that you keep on writing stories like this ^^

Cheers and Happy New Year!

L.D.
12/21/2007 c10 katara's twin
poor aang. but i'm a zutarian so i really don't disagree that much with how stuff has currently turned out. cheers for the new year!

katara's twin
12/20/2007 c19 andrew
this is awesome and i think this should happin in am episode of avatar. i personally like kataang and i hope zuko and katara can be friends.
12/14/2007 c19 sparkysparkyboomman
Though I ship Kataang, I thought this story was excellent. It shows how Aang and Katara should be together. Excellent job.
12/13/2007 c18 11MavsGirl22
Purely brilliant! I love your writing style and the ending was just absolutely perfect. The only suggestion I have is being careful with some of your word usage (I'm a culprit of this as well...) I noticed a couple of times you used "career" when I think you meant "Careen". I've found that reading through it outloud helps pick up on this type of mistake/typo.

But, again, beautifully done! I can't wait to read more of your work!
12/13/2007 c8 MavsGirl22
You've compeletly sucked me into this story! Well Done! "His posture is tragic" I don't know why... but I just love that line. I'm still astounded at how well you wrap up the chapters, including dialouge and awesome descriptions, in so few words. It's truely inspiring!
12/13/2007 c3 MavsGirl22
You're writing is absolutely addicting! I normally don't enjoy first person fics, but this is absolutely amazing. I love your style! And great metaphor with the "pushing and pulling" of Katara since she's a waterbender and all. Kudos! :)
168 P 1 3 Last Next »

Regular Site . Blog . Twitter . Help . Sign Up  Top