for The Anatomy of Melancholy2/20/2012 c1 i-Spit-on-Fire
I am speechless. That was, wow. Ok I REALLY cant find a word to describe this.
I am speechless. That was, wow. Ok I REALLY cant find a word to describe this.
2/6/2012 c1 HaganeJonetsu
Wow. That was...really heartwrenching.
Seeing Haruhi like that makes me feel...so melancholic myself.
Great oneshot.
Wow. That was...really heartwrenching.
Seeing Haruhi like that makes me feel...so melancholic myself.
Great oneshot.
1/29/2012 c1 Guardian-of-Knowledge-and-Fate
Wonderful story! This is one of the best interpretations of this series that I have ever read! Keep up the good work!
Wonderful story! This is one of the best interpretations of this series that I have ever read! Keep up the good work!
1/28/2012 c1 
2justbehappydammit
Oh...Oh god. That...That is the saddest thing ever. And so very believable.
2justbehappydammitOh...Oh god. That...That is the saddest thing ever. And so very believable.
1/21/2012 c1 2Zukemon
This is probably the best interpretation I've seen of the Haruhi universe. It made me re-evaluate the series and finding new interpretations of certain events.
I also loved what you did with the inserts of "The ... of Haruhi Suzumiya" It reminded me of the running "I am Jack's..." joke from fight club and I found myself reading them with the same deadpan tone.
This is without a doubt the best story in this category that I've read. Keep up the superb work.
2ZukemonThis is probably the best interpretation I've seen of the Haruhi universe. It made me re-evaluate the series and finding new interpretations of certain events.
I also loved what you did with the inserts of "The ... of Haruhi Suzumiya" It reminded me of the running "I am Jack's..." joke from fight club and I found myself reading them with the same deadpan tone.
This is without a doubt the best story in this category that I've read. Keep up the superb work.
1/18/2012 c1 2Not-Always-Fanfiction
This is really good, I love your idea, and I want to ask you to continue this, it would be a great story, although I don't see how you would finish this.
2Not-Always-FanfictionThis is really good, I love your idea, and I want to ask you to continue this, it would be a great story, although I don't see how you would finish this.
1/16/2012 c1 1HerbCurb7
Amazing rendition of the story! I have a few other renditions too! Thank you for writing this!
1HerbCurb7Amazing rendition of the story! I have a few other renditions too! Thank you for writing this!
11/28/2011 c1 44Lady Nightwisp
Wow. Just, wow.
This was beautiful. Very sad, but amazing.
I was in tears by the end. And I never cry at anything.
44Lady NightwispWow. Just, wow.
This was beautiful. Very sad, but amazing.
I was in tears by the end. And I never cry at anything.
11/22/2011 c1 14Duwee Davis II
This... is... wonderful. That's all I have to say. An excellent interpretation of the series, you wrote it so well that it's convincing in it's own way...
14Duwee Davis IIThis... is... wonderful. That's all I have to say. An excellent interpretation of the series, you wrote it so well that it's convincing in it's own way...
10/12/2011 c1 34katie janeway
I don't really know what to say beyond mentioning that I'm impressed. There were some minor grammatical/spelling errors in the fic, but I was too caught up in the narrative to really notice them.
34katie janewayI don't really know what to say beyond mentioning that I'm impressed. There were some minor grammatical/spelling errors in the fic, but I was too caught up in the narrative to really notice them.
9/26/2011 c1 88The Queen of Double Standards
This was amazing. It's so creative and emotional. Fabulous job!
88The Queen of Double StandardsThis was amazing. It's so creative and emotional. Fabulous job!
9/5/2011 c1 9Demon-Something
I loved your twisting of the canon into something so tragic. A fic like this is rare, and yours has left me speechless. Great job.
9Demon-SomethingI loved your twisting of the canon into something so tragic. A fic like this is rare, and yours has left me speechless. Great job.