for Another Road not Taken12/3/2011 c20 MalSer
Enjoyed the chapter but I would have liked a more detailed/dramatic description of the Hub being destroyed. I like to be able to see major events in my head as they happen (if that makes any sense) and it seemed a little anti-climatic to me. Just a suggestion, definitely looking forward to more chapters!
Enjoyed the chapter but I would have liked a more detailed/dramatic description of the Hub being destroyed. I like to be able to see major events in my head as they happen (if that makes any sense) and it seemed a little anti-climatic to me. Just a suggestion, definitely looking forward to more chapters!
11/12/2011 c19 
16thedarkpokemaster
Damn this was sweet still were are the twos they have to be around some where
16thedarkpokemasterDamn this was sweet still were are the twos they have to be around some where
11/12/2011 c19 4Major Simi
well a good fight. a ship going down whit a big bang and taking one last enemy whit it. good chapter
4Major Simiwell a good fight. a ship going down whit a big bang and taking one last enemy whit it. good chapter
11/11/2011 c19 MalSer
Enjoyed the update and things are heating up...looking forward to more. Thanks!
Enjoyed the update and things are heating up...looking forward to more. Thanks!
11/8/2011 c18 1doctor chocolate thunder
what they did to the cylon you are speaking of is really quite common in war. i thought it was actually a bit tame especially when you consider she played a killing 50 billion people. The fact is that sort of thing happens in all wars(abu gharaib). fortunately we usualy prosecute those kinds of things, many countries do not.
1doctor chocolate thunderwhat they did to the cylon you are speaking of is really quite common in war. i thought it was actually a bit tame especially when you consider she played a killing 50 billion people. The fact is that sort of thing happens in all wars(abu gharaib). fortunately we usualy prosecute those kinds of things, many countries do not.
10/28/2011 c4 3BoredZero
First off, thanks for writing a Stargate Battlestar crossover story. This is a combination that has a lot of potential and not enough stories.
However, your depiction of the SG weapons and ships seem incredibly nerfed when you compare Cylon and Colonial technology next to Stargate technology.
For instance, the shields (and subsequently, the nukes).
You say that the shields on a 304 cannot last long under numerous Raider squadrons.
Raiders can carry conventional or nuclear missiles and have cannons on board. We know that the yield of the nukes used in Battlestar Galactica are a mere fraction of those used in Stargate SG-1, since the biggest nuke we hear of in BSG is a fifty kiloton. Granted, they make up for this by having multiple nukes.
In the early seasons of Stargate when the Go'a'uld come to attack Earth with two Ha'taks, Area 51 launches two missiles that "yield in excess of one thousand megatons". The Go'a'uld's shields took this and shrugged it off like nothing.
The Asgard shields are known to be more powerful than those of the Go'a'ulds. So how can the Asgard based shields of the 304 fail under what is essentially, small arms fire and low yield nukes? A fifty kiloton nuke wouldn't do crap against the Asgard shields, much less sustained small arms fire.
And what happened to the Asgard beam weapons? Since you mention "Asgard-designed" equipment a few times, that means the Prometheus you are using is after the last episode of Season 10, Prometheus Unbound.
Heck, a single Mk VII alone would wreck havoc against a Cylon fleet from the blast alone.
3BoredZeroFirst off, thanks for writing a Stargate Battlestar crossover story. This is a combination that has a lot of potential and not enough stories.
However, your depiction of the SG weapons and ships seem incredibly nerfed when you compare Cylon and Colonial technology next to Stargate technology.
For instance, the shields (and subsequently, the nukes).
You say that the shields on a 304 cannot last long under numerous Raider squadrons.
Raiders can carry conventional or nuclear missiles and have cannons on board. We know that the yield of the nukes used in Battlestar Galactica are a mere fraction of those used in Stargate SG-1, since the biggest nuke we hear of in BSG is a fifty kiloton. Granted, they make up for this by having multiple nukes.
In the early seasons of Stargate when the Go'a'uld come to attack Earth with two Ha'taks, Area 51 launches two missiles that "yield in excess of one thousand megatons". The Go'a'uld's shields took this and shrugged it off like nothing.
The Asgard shields are known to be more powerful than those of the Go'a'ulds. So how can the Asgard based shields of the 304 fail under what is essentially, small arms fire and low yield nukes? A fifty kiloton nuke wouldn't do crap against the Asgard shields, much less sustained small arms fire.
And what happened to the Asgard beam weapons? Since you mention "Asgard-designed" equipment a few times, that means the Prometheus you are using is after the last episode of Season 10, Prometheus Unbound.
Heck, a single Mk VII alone would wreck havoc against a Cylon fleet from the blast alone.