for The Unlikeliest Relationships in Arda4/23/2012 c12 
26CrackinAndProudOfIt
How on earth do you make these completely plausible? *grins, sighs, and shakes head* It's so wild and farfetched, but it actually made sense- and 'twas quite well-written, too! I enjoy these so much!
-Crackers
26CrackinAndProudOfItHow on earth do you make these completely plausible? *grins, sighs, and shakes head* It's so wild and farfetched, but it actually made sense- and 'twas quite well-written, too! I enjoy these so much!
-Crackers
4/6/2012 c11 26CrackinAndProudOfIt
Oh, yes, quite clever! :) I liked how you paired them together based on their spouses' similarities! I could so easily see this idea turning into a quite vicious soap opera! ;) Good work!
-Crackers
26CrackinAndProudOfItOh, yes, quite clever! :) I liked how you paired them together based on their spouses' similarities! I could so easily see this idea turning into a quite vicious soap opera! ;) Good work!
-Crackers
4/5/2012 c11 8The Random Hummingbird
Indeed, what could have been. Now I'm really wondering how they could've met...Anyway, a nice chapter!
8The Random HummingbirdIndeed, what could have been. Now I'm really wondering how they could've met...Anyway, a nice chapter!
3/23/2012 c10 26CrackinAndProudOfIt
I liked it! The context of their meeting actually made quite a bit of sense! :) It was nice to see a young Lobelia- and it seems she 'showed more spirit than most' even then. ;) Nicely done, and completely insane!
-Crackers ;D
26CrackinAndProudOfItI liked it! The context of their meeting actually made quite a bit of sense! :) It was nice to see a young Lobelia- and it seems she 'showed more spirit than most' even then. ;) Nicely done, and completely insane!
-Crackers ;D
1/15/2012 c9 26CrackinAndProudOfIt
I actually liked your Kipling imitation! It was very well-done and funny! :) I don't believe I shall ever look at a dolphin the same, though... ;) I liked it, all the same!
-Crackers =)
26CrackinAndProudOfItI actually liked your Kipling imitation! It was very well-done and funny! :) I don't believe I shall ever look at a dolphin the same, though... ;) I liked it, all the same!
-Crackers =)
1/13/2012 c7 38Mornen
I like Orodreth. He's a horrible king, but I think he's very sweet. I can't answer your question, seeing how this is the only story I've read in this series, but I did like it. It was funny in a strange way.
38MornenI like Orodreth. He's a horrible king, but I think he's very sweet. I can't answer your question, seeing how this is the only story I've read in this series, but I did like it. It was funny in a strange way.
12/11/2011 c2 3Amy M. Black
Poor Maedhros. He is always involved in slash stuff. That serves him well for not marrying and having kids, it leaves a lot to the imagination xD. I didn't even remember Amlach until you wrote him here, but he totally sounds like that kind of badass ;)
3Amy M. BlackPoor Maedhros. He is always involved in slash stuff. That serves him well for not marrying and having kids, it leaves a lot to the imagination xD. I didn't even remember Amlach until you wrote him here, but he totally sounds like that kind of badass ;)
12/11/2011 c7 Amy M. Black
This is my other favorite. I never really liked Orodreth much, as he, as you said, is not really a leader and just listens to everyone. But "I can see this totally happening". He just sounds like the kind of guy that just goes on with the fight, even if he has nothing to fight for. He doesn't even hate them, he stands there out of resignation. And yeah, this would kick Edward/Bella to a corner and leave them there crying xD.
This is my other favorite. I never really liked Orodreth much, as he, as you said, is not really a leader and just listens to everyone. But "I can see this totally happening". He just sounds like the kind of guy that just goes on with the fight, even if he has nothing to fight for. He doesn't even hate them, he stands there out of resignation. And yeah, this would kick Edward/Bella to a corner and leave them there crying xD.
12/11/2011 c5 Amy M. Black
Hey! at first, when I read the title of this fic, I expected it to be much more sort of parody. But you make them seem totally plausible. This one is one of my favorites, even if each chapter is a little pearl among the sea of unlikely pairings in fanfiction. Even if I think Anárion was married by the time he left Númenor, as his son Meneldil was born there, I can totally see this happening. And I love the way Míriel teases him about how different he is from the King's Men. His thoughts about Lúthien and Míriel are just priceless. And you make her look like she had little part on what Pharazôn did, which I always believed to be that way. Even if she panicked at the very end. Sorry for the long review but as I said, I really enjoyed this story. Keep writing :)
Hey! at first, when I read the title of this fic, I expected it to be much more sort of parody. But you make them seem totally plausible. This one is one of my favorites, even if each chapter is a little pearl among the sea of unlikely pairings in fanfiction. Even if I think Anárion was married by the time he left Númenor, as his son Meneldil was born there, I can totally see this happening. And I love the way Míriel teases him about how different he is from the King's Men. His thoughts about Lúthien and Míriel are just priceless. And you make her look like she had little part on what Pharazôn did, which I always believed to be that way. Even if she panicked at the very end. Sorry for the long review but as I said, I really enjoyed this story. Keep writing :)
11/29/2011 c8 26CrackinAndProudOfIt
A very interesting one, to be sure! ;) But I liked it a lot! Your twists on the stories are so very intriguing and thought-provoking. I liked how you let her story mirror that of her namesake, and also how the last line is said by Aragorn in the movies! :) Great work!
-Crackers
26CrackinAndProudOfItA very interesting one, to be sure! ;) But I liked it a lot! Your twists on the stories are so very intriguing and thought-provoking. I liked how you let her story mirror that of her namesake, and also how the last line is said by Aragorn in the movies! :) Great work!
-Crackers
11/28/2011 c8 20Galad Estel
I love the irony of the foreshadowing. Aragorn to noble to usurp Denethor's place. Denethor should really worry now. Aragorn might just kill him and marry his wife. He just needs to get him out in the wild. No. I am kidding Aragorn would never do that but...
Have you thought of your next pair? You could something like Celeborn and Nerdanel, or is that not unlikely enough? They are both married to the two most powerful Elves who leave them and are both noted as wise, ah well, you'll think of something
20Galad EstelI love the irony of the foreshadowing. Aragorn to noble to usurp Denethor's place. Denethor should really worry now. Aragorn might just kill him and marry his wife. He just needs to get him out in the wild. No. I am kidding Aragorn would never do that but...
Have you thought of your next pair? You could something like Celeborn and Nerdanel, or is that not unlikely enough? They are both married to the two most powerful Elves who leave them and are both noted as wise, ah well, you'll think of something
11/23/2011 c7 8The Random Hummingbird
These always amaze me. At every chapter, I'm thinking, "There is no way to make that happen, it's just impossible." Yet at the end of the chapter I'm saying, "I can totally see that happening." These stories just open my eyes completely.
As for this chapter, I never really think about Orodreth (the poor guy, he's always left out of everything), much less about him being paired with Morgoth's vampire messenger, but you made it seem entirely possible. The only thing I didn't really like was Thurinwethil's size, I always thought she would take the form of a very large bat, rather than a smaller one, but I suppose that depends on your individual view.
I eagerly await more!
8The Random HummingbirdThese always amaze me. At every chapter, I'm thinking, "There is no way to make that happen, it's just impossible." Yet at the end of the chapter I'm saying, "I can totally see that happening." These stories just open my eyes completely.
As for this chapter, I never really think about Orodreth (the poor guy, he's always left out of everything), much less about him being paired with Morgoth's vampire messenger, but you made it seem entirely possible. The only thing I didn't really like was Thurinwethil's size, I always thought she would take the form of a very large bat, rather than a smaller one, but I suppose that depends on your individual view.
I eagerly await more!