for The Musings of Maglor12/8/2011 c1 
26CrackinAndProudOfIt
I thought it was very well-done. I enjoyed the format of it as a record found by Frodo and placed in the Red Book, as well as the study of the characters and their relationships. I thought the dream sequence was very well-written and powerful, though at first I'll admit I was a little confused and thought it was some sort of AU version of the Darkening of Valinor. I agree that it could use more detail, and I would definitely love to see it be made into a longer, multi-chapter work. I hope that was helpful! :)
-Crackers
26CrackinAndProudOfItI thought it was very well-done. I enjoyed the format of it as a record found by Frodo and placed in the Red Book, as well as the study of the characters and their relationships. I thought the dream sequence was very well-written and powerful, though at first I'll admit I was a little confused and thought it was some sort of AU version of the Darkening of Valinor. I agree that it could use more detail, and I would definitely love to see it be made into a longer, multi-chapter work. I hope that was helpful! :)
-Crackers