"N-no...Finn, I can't take it anymore,"
Rachel's soft voice cracked a little as she moaned and tried to struggle, but Finn was much stronger than her. Her dads had been out of town for a week, and there was no one to hear her screams. Rachel bit her lips.
Finn looked a bit uncomfortable and stopped what he was doing. He kissed Rachel's forehead and whispered in a careful voice. Finn's breath on her ears made Rachel shiver.
"Rachel, you were the one who asked me, right? It's for your own good. So please, just bear with it."
Although tears were slowly streaming down her face, Rachel managed to nod weakly. Finn smiled and sat straight. He grabbed the lotion bottle under the pillow. They had applied some lotion before they started, but as Rachel's moans and shrieks suggested, it was still too rough for her.
Finn squeezed white lotion from the bottle onto his palm and covered his fin, gers with it. Rachel stole a glance at Finn's hands, always so warm and firm, but instead of safety and warmth, they looked intimidating now. 'Are they always this big?' Rachel thought to herself.
"Okay, I think we should take another go at it." Finn examined his hands and looked satisfied.
"S-sure, but please gentle." Said Rachel as she wiped the tears off her face.
"You know, Rachel, it's rare to see you so...uhh...different like this." Finn sounded amused.
Finn placed his slippery and sticky index finger slowly on Rachel's face. The brunette held her breath and closed her eyes, bracing for the impact. Slowly, Finn's finger massaged the tip of Rachel's nose. Finn's thumb, middle, and ring fingers joined, and soon enough Rachel's nose was covered in a thin layer of lotion. Finn's index finger traced the edges of Rachel's right nostril...
"..Not so fast," Rachel said, without opening her eyes. Finn sighed.
"At this point, we won't finish until next year, Rachel. Should we just stop this?"
"N-No! I'm sorry, okay? Just...continue. But please..."
"...be gentle, yeah, I know."
Finn continued to massage and caress the tip of Rachel's nose for a while, and moved down to the edges of her nostrils. Rachel let out a moan and gritted her teeth. Although he normally wouldn't have the heart to continue, he had made a promise to Rachel to follow through with this, and to ignore her refusals. And even though he wouldn't ever say it out loud, he also wanted to cry, seeing Rachel so sad and vulnerable like this. Finn braced himself, and with a quick thrust, slipped his index finger into Rachel's right nostril. Rachel's body shook and she blinked. It felt so wrong, but he must admit that the insides of Rachel's nose was so warm and soft. Instinctively, Finn moved his finger deeper inside Rachel's nostril, feeling warm air everytime she let out her breath. It slipped so easily, partially because of the lotion.
He continued moving his finger in and out, allowing Rachel to get used to the movement. Rachel's body slowly became less stiff and she opened her eyes, looking at Finn's own eyes with burning determination. Finn smiled, and this time, Rachel returned that smile.
As his right index finger continued to move inside Rachel's right nostril, Finn steadily moved his left index finger onto Rachel's nose. And keeping the steady rhythm inside Rachel's right nostril, Finn's left index finger entered Rachel's other nostril. Rachel gasped and opened her mouth to take air, her nasal passage completely blocked by Finn's sizely fingers.
Rachel had never felt anything like this in her life before. Sure, she had picked her nose once or twice before, in the privacy of her room, since it was such an unladylike behaviour, but to have someone else's finger inside her nose was such a completely different sensation. It felt so wrong and dirty, but at the same time, so...warming, as it was as if their body became one.
And just as Rachel began to felt the ectasy in her nose, they heard the front door open. Rachel's blood froze. Finn looked pale and confused.
"I...I think it must be my dads! They said they'd arrive this evening! We should just continue this later, Finn! I can't let them see us like this!"
"Y-Yeah, of course! Urgh..."
Finn pulled both of his fingers inside Rachel's nose, but...
"I...I think they're stuck!"