Just In
Community » TV Shows » Supernatural » Best Original Character Supernatural Stories

Focus: TV Shows » Supernatural, Since: 10-18-13
Founder: Littlemissflames - Stories: 389 - Followers: 149 - Staff: 1 - id: 110695
A collection of the best supernatural stories with OCs. They'll mostly be longer stories but a few one shots that are really good are in here too...if you find any that I haven't added, just pm me and I'll add them :D

28 The Thing That Should Not Be » by Raissi Jenna had seen demons her entire life. Her whole life she'd been told she was crazy. Eventually she had even believed it. Now these two brothers were telling her demons were real. Caught in the middle of a civil war in Hell, with Crowley on one side and Malphas, Prince of Hell & former second in command to Lucifer, on the other. It's not just her soul on the line. Crowley/OC
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Supernatural, chapters: 24, words: 93k+, favs: 134, follows: 91, updated: 12/4/2017 published: 6/30/2017, [Crowley, OC] Dean W., Castiel
172Game of Shadows » by VivatRex [S10 AU] A new Knight of Hell, a new Prophet, one more shot at Armageddon, and another civil war in Heaven. Same song, different verse. But who's playing the tune this time?
Supernatural, T, English, Drama & Angst, chapters: 39, words: 159k+, favs: 87, follows: 113, updated: 10/29/2018 published: 9/9/2014, [Dean W., Castiel] Sam W., Crowley
2 Goons & Goddesses Episode I Moonlight Madness » by HalfbreedHunter Part 1 Moonlight Madness Sam and Dean meet Maggie on a vampire hunt. Maggie has the Winchesters at odds with her high maintenance antics. Reviews appreciated. Artwork use permitted by the talented endi-z.
Supernatural, T, English, Supernatural & Adventure, chapters: 5, words: 18k+, favs: 5, follows: 5, updated: 12/2/2017 published: 6/2/2017, Sam W., Dean W.
19Antiquity » by IronSparrow99 What if Cassie wasn't Dean's only "old friend"? Enter Alexandria: she's kicking supernatural butt and taking demonic names. She knew the Winchesters, once, but they left - and that was that. Or so she thought. But then a certain hunter waltzes into a bar, ten years later, asking for her help in finding his father. Can she dive back in? Does she even have a choice in the matter?
Supernatural, T, English, Sci-Fi & Suspense, chapters: 15, words: 43k+, favs: 76, follows: 75, updated: 9/26/2017 published: 3/29/2017, Sam W., Dean W., John W., OC
Sophia's Memories » by QuietAspirations Based on my other fic, Sophia's Chronicles. This will explore Sophia's early life - God/Amara rivalry, who Sophia really is and the archangels. Backstory to my main fic. Will definitely show how the romance between Lucifer/Sophia developed and heavily features archangels. A lot of fluff! First 4 chaps are abt why God adopted Sophia so skip to Chp5 if you don't want that.
Supernatural, K+, English, Romance & Family, chapters: 11, words: 31k+, favs: 19, follows: 18, updated: 6/1/2018 published: 3/28/2017, Chuck S./God, Lucifer, Gabriel, OC
63 Playing With Fire » by Aini NuFire Sequel to "A Fire Shall Be Woken" - When Charlie unearths the Book of the Damned, she draws the attention of the notorious Styne family, who will stop at nothing to get it back. And even with the help of an angel and a phoenix, the Winchesters might have bitten off more than they can chew…
Supernatural, T, English, Friendship & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 7, words: 21k+, favs: 57, follows: 28, updated: 4/3/2017 published: 3/13/2017, Sam W., Dean W., Castiel, OC
82 A Fire Shall Be Woken » by Aini NuFire Sequel to "From the Ashes" - Castiel's grace is fading, and a spell to recover the memories Naomi erased backfires, leaving him in a coma. Now the Winchesters and a new ally have to find a way to restore Cas's grace before he fades away completely.
Supernatural, T, English, Angst & Drama, chapters: 8, words: 28k+, favs: 73, follows: 31, updated: 11/11/2016 published: 10/17/2016, Sam W., Dean W., Castiel, OC
93 From the Ashes » by Aini NuFire When Castiel seeks out someone who may be able to remove the Mark from Dean, he discovers a link to a past that Naomi had taken from him. But searching for answers and a cure will have to be put on hold when Cain begins a rampage to end his bloodline—and Dean.
Supernatural, T, English, Drama & Angst, chapters: 7, words: 24k+, favs: 101, follows: 55, updated: 10/14/2016 published: 9/23/2016, Dean W., Castiel, OC, Cain
15 Mourning Pie » by DarkandTwistedSisters BOOK 2 in our series. Life has been pretty good for our Bakers since they last met our favorite Hunters. But all that changes the morning they receive a strange call from John. Can the girls hold themselves together, bake a few pies and comfort the guys? Or will they each get lost in their own pain and suffering, leaving Bobby to pick up the pieces? COMPLETE
Supernatural, T, English, Drama & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 13, words: 39k+, favs: 19, follows: 13, updated: 5/27/2016 published: 8/27/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Bobby S., OC
35 Witch Pie? » by DarkandTwistedSisters Meet Mae and Lilly, two unlikely friends turned business partners that end up meeting the boys under some incriminating circumstances. Assumptions are made. Pie is eaten. John is still missing and Bobby's no where to be found. Are these girls really witches? Or is there more happening than meets the eye? BOOK 1 of our Bakers, Hunters and Pie series! Rated T for language.
Supernatural, T, English, Drama & Suspense, chapters: 16, words: 48k+, favs: 60, follows: 39, updated: 5/27/2016 published: 6/19/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Bobby S., OC
65 Bloody Ashes Are All I Have » by Kinthinia Andrea has nothing, and the one goodness she has left, she's asked to kill it. Marissa's lost everything, but she holds onto kindness. With the dead rising and a trap underway, the Winchesters are the only hope and despair they have.
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 27, words: 83k+, favs: 34, follows: 25, updated: 12/10/2011 published: 1/16/2011, Sam W., Dean W., OC
18 A Supernatural Battle of Wills » by krissymcmahon Sam and Dean call on a pair of sisters who've made a name for themselves as hunters when it appears that they are somehow at the root of the latest case they've found themselves involved in. Introduces original characters Stevie and Maria Hilliard and Bobbie Ann Peterson.
Supernatural, T, English, Sci-Fi & Supernatural, chapters: 50, words: 55k+, favs: 36, follows: 33, updated: 7/26/2016 published: 5/30/2016, Sam W., Dean W., Castiel, OC
3The Pursuit (A Supernatural Story) » by MeechieNikole One moment, one mistake can change everything. Anya will have to decide whether she chooses sanity and love or to be consumed by the pursuit of vengeance.
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Supernatural, chapters: 4, words: 14k+, favs: 2, follows: 1, updated: 8/23/2016 published: 6/13/2016
104The Supernatural Adventures of Ellie Singer » by lucyinthefandom Ellie Singer is the best female friend the Winchesters never had. Based on canon episodes of Supernatural, this story inserts Ellie into the action as friend, ally and companion.
Supernatural, T, English, Supernatural & Adventure, chapters: 94, words: 367k+, favs: 255, follows: 263, updated: 1/25/2017 published: 2/22/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Bobby S., OC
23As You Are » by n-nymphet Orphaned for the second time, Quincy Johnson begs the Winchesters to take her in so she won't have to endure another three years in foster care. When they do, things become tense. Can they make things work? Or will Quincy be sent away like all the other times before?
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Supernatural, chapters: 4, words: 11k+, favs: 39, follows: 66, updated: 4/6/2016 published: 11/19/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Castiel, OC
82 A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes » by MercedesRayne Months after her high school graduation, Anastasia Walker begins to have dreams and nightmares about two brothers saving the world from the things that go bump in the night. For the first few months of dealing with the hectic dreams she's able to cope as best she can, but when she begins to see these things while she's awake she can no longer ignore them.
Supernatural, T, English, Supernatural & Drama, chapters: 76, words: 398k+, favs: 181, follows: 168, updated: 7/13/2020 published: 6/30/2015, Sam W., Dean W., OC
127 My better half » by dianaclaudia Sam and Dean meet their female selves. Emma and Melody Bennett. Doppelgangers. Also hunters. Also hunted by angels. (Emma and Melody are my original characters. Double pairing later in the story. SEQUEL available)
Supernatural, T, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 40, words: 112k+, favs: 197, follows: 143, updated: 3/19/2016 published: 2/2/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Castiel, OC
52The Family Business » by R. W. Winters I'm Alex Winchester. I've been mute since the night of the nursery fire and no one knows why, but that hasn't stopped me from hunting with my two brothers, Sam and Dean. Our dad disappeared recently and we're setting aside our differences to try and find him. This... could get interesting. PREQUEL to Song Remains the Same. Sisfic. (Discontinued)
Supernatural, T, English, Drama & Family, chapters: 4, words: 58k+, favs: 215, follows: 230, updated: 3/2/2014 published: 8/8/2013, Sam W., Dean W., OC
31 The Story of Supernatural » by AfireLove1998 Shia Colten-Singer is the adoptive daughter of Bobby Singer. Growing up, her life was normal, two parents and a white picket fence. Shia's life took an odd turn when a woman appears in her room, claiming to be her mother. Now, she's hunting down demons, ghosts, and ghouls along with the Winchester brothers. [Vol 1. Seasons 1-3]. Dean x OC.
Supernatural, T, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 44, words: 288k+, favs: 246, follows: 174, updated: 5/10/2017 published: 6/6/2015, [Dean W., OC] Sam W.
6 The Usual Suspects » by The Last Donna Sarah Singer wasn't your usual twenty-something, she led a second life that many do not know about. Being Bobby Singer's daughter isn't easy sometimes, but she makes it through. She alsoprotects people from things that go bump in the night but will she be able to protect herself from the Winchesters.
Supernatural, T, English, Supernatural & Romance, chapters: 12, words: 13k+, favs: 24, follows: 23, updated: 1/11/2016 published: 10/11/2014, Sam W., Dean W., Bobby S., OC
78 Foolish Endeavours » by SassyPrincess14 Sophie lost her mother the day she turned six months old. She has been peacefully living her life with her best friend Rowan. About a year ago, she began to develop the gift to read people's thoughts. Everything is normal to her until Sam and Dean Winchester show up on her front door. Starts after S2E10 when Sam asks Ash to find others like him. Dean/OC sequel: Freewill Over Fate.
Supernatural, T, English, Romance, chapters: 29, words: 41k+, favs: 191, follows: 151, updated: 12/28/2015 published: 4/11/2014, [Dean W., OC] Sam W.
2Song Drabbles » by SiriusHorcrux1018 [A collection of one-shots inspired by a variety of songs) Chapter 2: Sam remembers things about Jess all too well.
Supernatural, T, English, chapters: 2, words: 3k+, favs: 2, follows: 1, updated: 3/10/2015 published: 2/9/2015, Sam W., Dean W.
406 The Kids Aren't Alright » by wimsicalpan (Continuation of Kiddy Corral) Dean is back from hell. He's got questions. What brought him back? When did the fate of the world rest on their shoulders? What has Sam been doing? And what the hell is wrong with Charlotte? Set season 4 onwards. (Dean/OC and hint of Sam/OC different OC) - Updates Thursdays!
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 98, words: 237k+, favs: 291, follows: 317, updated: 8/31/2017 published: 2/10/2015, [Dean W., OC] Sam W.
708 Kiddy Corral » by wimsicalpan John wasn't the only hunter Bobby babysat the kids for. (Lots of Pre-series. Dean/OC eventually with lots of other character interactions thrown in. Slight AU in some places. Will follow the series eventually.) A look into the boys lives as they grew up -with one addition. (FINISHED)
Supernatural, T, English, Romance & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 96, words: 174k+, favs: 874, follows: 644, updated: 8/31/2017 published: 7/19/2013, [Dean W., OC]
5 You Either Die A Hero » by MidnightMadwoman A grim alternate Season 10: Demon!Dean has his brother professionally darkened, and finds out the hard way that Soulless!Sam isn't that much fun to hang out with. Meanwhile, Crowley makes friends with the doctor that extracts human souls, and Cole and his son hunt Dean with furious vengeance. Featuring Charlie, Latin trash talk, Crowley the Grammar-Nazi and Dean getting lost. DONE!
Supernatural, T, English, Horror & Supernatural, chapters: 10, words: 61k+, favs: 22, follows: 18, updated: 3/15/2016 published: 1/31/2015, Sam W., Dean W., Crowley, Rowena M.
205 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »

Twitter . Help . Sign Up . Cookies . Privacy . Terms of Service