Comfort of a Father » by Destiel101 Alternate take on Blessed Are the Peacemakers because Arthur didn't get the comfort he deserved.
T, English, Family & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 10, words: 10k+, favs: 2, follows: 2, updated: 5h published: 4/3, D. v. d. Linde, Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Hosea Trelawny
2The Outlaw's Daughter » by SapphireShelle91 The first four years of Lizzie Morgan's life were quiet & safe. But then the bad men came & with two gun shots, Lizzie's world was forever changed. Hiding beneath the floorboards of a once loving now empty home, her Daddy finds her. Without any other choice, Arthur Morgan takes her with him, to live amongst the van der Linde gang & Lizzie learns how to be loyal to what matters.
T, English, Family & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 4, words: 16k+, favs: 5, follows: 12, updated: 5/4 published: 1/26, OC, Arthur Morgan
A Modest Night in a Lovely Town by Pairiny10 Kieran is sent out to find Bill after he went to the Rhodes saloon and bring him back to camp. However, plans soon change after Kieran realizes that Bill is too drunk to make it back to camp and decides that it's best they spend the night in a hotel.
T, English, Romance & Humor, words: 3k+, 5/2, [Bill Williamson, Kieran Duffy]
2Heal Behind the Trigger » by ElectricBlaster Samuel Hawkeson, assistant at one of Valentine's local clinics, finds his life changed once the town is raided by O'Driscolls. With his cousin at his side, and surrounded by outlaws, Sam enters the fool's game for vengeance and meets a man fighting his own battle of good versus evil. Will Sam lose himself to revenge, or can he finally see the value of honor?
T, English, Adventure & Drama, chapters: 8, words: 62k+, favs: 5, follows: 9, updated: 5/1 published: 9/20/2020, [Arthur Morgan, OC] D. v. d. Linde, John Marston
13Dreams to Daylight » by RivetingRosie4 After having lost Eliza & Isaac and avenging their deaths, Arthur struggles to cope and keeps his grief intensely private, refraining from even journaling about them. His intense emotions grapple with him until they leak into his dreams, the only outlet he's left for them. Memories first, then regrets, then wishes and lovely imaginings for what could've been.
T, English, Western & Family, chapters: 19, words: 117k+, favs: 10, follows: 8, updated: 4/29 published: 10/22/2020, Arthur Morgan
1The Sun and the Moon » by MarinersRevenge A collection of Arthur/Tilly one shots spanning different AUs
T, English, Romance & Angst, chapters: 13, words: 18k+, favs: 6, follows: 5, updated: 4/23 published: 8/27/2020, Arthur Morgan
11Rearrange the Stars » by whyyouacknsocraycray When Eliza is killed by robbers, Arthur Morgan decides to bring his son, Isaac, back to the gang. The addition of a child causes some adjustments for all gang members, but Arthur is left wondering whether or not he can balance the outlaw life and fatherhood.
T, English, Hurt/Comfort & Family, chapters: 14, words: 51k+, favs: 23, follows: 34, updated: 4/23 published: 1/23, Arthur Morgan, Dutch, John Marston
No Such Thing As Redemption (Redo) » by RavingRedemption Ada and her siblings, Dakota and Flint, meet a man one day going by the name Dutch van der Linde. Without knowing they get taken into the Van der Linde gangs early rising. As Ada grows she follows in Dutch's footsteps more and more. When the gang falls Ada will do whatever she can to try to ensure her and siblings survival...
T, English, chapters: 2, words: 4k+, favs: 1, follows: 2, updated: 4/17 published: 4/10
3Inner demons » by Rositadixon321 Colt Morgan was a bounty hunter trying to find his way and his family. When he finds what he looking for and is pulled away from it. Will it be for the best or for the worse.
T, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 8, words: 11k+, favs: 3, follows: 7, updated: 4/14 published: 3/18, [OC, Sadie Alder] Arthur Morgan, Dutch
135Safe and Sound » by Flufferz After her mother dies Catherine Ross is sent to live with her Uncle. She tries to make the best of it only to be let down. All too soon, the little girl is forced to grow up and she learns life isn't easy or fair. Abandonment and abuse sour her view on life. Can one person truly change everything? A forbidden best friend is all she has in this world. Can it survive Edgar Ross?
T, English, Angst & Romance, chapters: 48, words: 124k+, favs: 80, follows: 82, updated: 4/5 published: 11/4/2012, [Ja. Marston, OC] E. Ross
All In Good Fun by whyyouacknsocraycray Sean recruits Charles to help with his April Fools' Day prank.
K, English, Humor & Western, words: 924, favs: 1, 4/1, Arthur Morgan, Lenny, Charles, Sean
Preserving Peace by miXiZ Arthur is mad. And Charles only sees one way to stop him from doing something he'd regret.
T, English, Drama, words: 1k+, favs: 1, 4/1, Arthur Morgan, Charles, D. v. d. Linde, Micah Bell
(Not) My Son by King Dollophead John Marston never expected to be a father. The thought hadn't even crossed his mind. As Abigail liked to remind him, he was a dangerous criminal; definitely not father-of-the-year material. However, it seems fate has a terrible sense of humor. There is absolutely no chance in hell he is cut out for fatherhood. i.e. John Marston and the fallout of his year-long absence.
T, English, Western & Hurt/Comfort, words: 2k+, favs: 1, follows: 1, 4/1, Arthur Morgan, Abigail, Jack M., John Marston
A Horse Is Waiting For You by LFD13 Arthur tried his best. And in the end, he made it.
K+, English, Spiritual & Hurt/Comfort, words: 184, favs: 1, follows: 1, 3/29, Arthur Morgan
Old Friend's Old Flame by MASTERMIND360 John was on his way home, and then he unexpectedly bump into someone he hardly knew.
T, English, Hurt/Comfort & Drama, words: 2k+, favs: 1, 3/29, John Marston
On a Pale Horse (Undead Nightmare) by LFD13 Death's thoughts. (I always wondered what horse John used to get home at the end of the game so I decided to do a fanfiction. Also, this story/one-shot takes place in Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare).
T, English, Supernatural, words: 258, favs: 1, 3/28, John Marston
1 Leads Back to You by Flufferz A short one-shot detailing the reunion between John Marston and his family after the events of "Red Dead Redemption" from Red Dead Redemption II. Title inspired by "Compass" by Jamie Lidell, one-shot inspired by a fan art by the-mill-kat on tumblr!
K+, English, Hurt/Comfort & Romance, words: 1k+, 3/18, Jo. Marston, A. Marston, Ja. Marston
Jake's Choices by Erzsebeth Bathory It was Jake's last day, and while he nor his wife knew it, he started off the morning with plans for their future.
T, English, Romance & Western, words: 1k+, favs: 1, 3/9
1 Stranger Mission: Boasting and Such » by She Who Walks With Trees A take on a stranger mission. Grace O'Neill struggles taking care of her family farm in her brother's absence. One day, a strange man shows up on her property, shot and wounded. Switches between OCs and Arthur's POV.
T, English, Western & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 15, words: 24k+, favs: 7, follows: 6, updated: 3/8 published: 1/19, OC, Arthur Morgan
We was family by Jaxmorganrdr A Red Dead Redemption 2 poem This one is about Dutch
K, English, Poetry, words: 120, 3/4, D. v. d. Linde
He was a man by Jaxmorganrdr A Red Dead Redemption 2 poem This one is about Arthur
K, English, Poetry, words: 187, 3/4, Arthur Morgan
Six Shots Deep by LFD13 (Spoilers!) Sequel to "Ride Or Die." While Arthur and John are out collecting bounties, they start to notice they're being watched. Meanwhile, Arthur's daughter Cecilia keeps poking her nose where it doesn't belong...
T, English, Fantasy & Spiritual, words: 572, 3/4, Arthur Morgan, John Marston, OC
Ride or Die » by LFD13 (SPOILERS!) Sequel to "Always With You." Arthur and the Marston family decide to visit the town of Strawberry for a little vacation. But when the spirits from their past return to finish them off, Arthur's instincts and skills are put to the test.
T, English, Spiritual & Family, chapters: 10, words: 5k+, favs: 1, follows: 2, updated: 3/3 published: 11/25/2020, Arthur Morgan, John Marston, D. v. d. Linde, Micah Bell
4 Arthur's Arabians by whyyouacknsocraycray In which Arthur finds four free Arabians, a whole lot of gold, and saves the gang!
T, English, Family & Western, words: 7k+, favs: 9, follows: 2, 2/23, Arthur Morgan, Dutch
2Lost As I Am, You're My Good Samaritan » by the49thname Arthur meets Albert Mason in the wilds and finds himself getting closer than he should. Stuck between the promise of a different life, and the life he has always lived, Arthur struggles to balance what he wants from what is deemed necessary.
T, English, Romance & Adventure, chapters: 2, words: 13k+, favs: 10, follows: 10, updated: 2/21 published: 12/21/2018, Arthur Morgan