for The Shadow of Angmar5/6 c31 rposter
This is my favorite fanfiction of all time. I've read it at least a half dozen times. While I still have hope that someday we'll get another chapter, the story is at a decent stopping point without big cliffhangers. I can deal with it staying as is.
I will, however, forever be annoyed that Harry's tree doesn't have a freaking name. It's lotr. Everything and everyone has 3 different names in 12 different languages. And the greatest creation of the entire third age doesn't get a name. Shame.
This is my favorite fanfiction of all time. I've read it at least a half dozen times. While I still have hope that someday we'll get another chapter, the story is at a decent stopping point without big cliffhangers. I can deal with it staying as is.
I will, however, forever be annoyed that Harry's tree doesn't have a freaking name. It's lotr. Everything and everyone has 3 different names in 12 different languages. And the greatest creation of the entire third age doesn't get a name. Shame.
4/27 c24 Falvern
I've lost count of how many times I've read this, but I completely forgot about this passage: "Then the silence was broken, and a voice called out to him. It was distant, faint, like the first star in the evening sky, but no less beautiful for all that. He could not understand the words it spoke, but he knew them, he knew their intent. Strength flowed through him once more, issued from some heretofore unknown font within him."
The imagery and allusion to the first star in the evening sky, leads me to think of Arwen being called the Evenstar. But it could also be Galadriel I suppose, or even someone or something else entirely. Though I'm honestly a fan of the idea of Harry/Arwen in this story. Especially with whatever Valar or entity that spoke to Harry referencing Beren being offered the same choice. And Arwen being compared to Luthien.
Though considering how long it has been since this story has been updated, I suppose we will never know unfortunately.
I've lost count of how many times I've read this, but I completely forgot about this passage: "Then the silence was broken, and a voice called out to him. It was distant, faint, like the first star in the evening sky, but no less beautiful for all that. He could not understand the words it spoke, but he knew them, he knew their intent. Strength flowed through him once more, issued from some heretofore unknown font within him."
The imagery and allusion to the first star in the evening sky, leads me to think of Arwen being called the Evenstar. But it could also be Galadriel I suppose, or even someone or something else entirely. Though I'm honestly a fan of the idea of Harry/Arwen in this story. Especially with whatever Valar or entity that spoke to Harry referencing Beren being offered the same choice. And Arwen being compared to Luthien.
Though considering how long it has been since this story has been updated, I suppose we will never know unfortunately.
4/19 c37 vansh4895
i just read the whole thing in one go and it was amazing! probably one of the best crossover fic I have read ever. Hope you find your way back to it someday.
i just read the whole thing in one go and it was amazing! probably one of the best crossover fic I have read ever. Hope you find your way back to it someday.
2/7 c37 
1Syllvanus
Heartbroken that this has been abandoned. One of my favorite crossovers. I hope you find the energy to work on it sometime soon!
1SyllvanusHeartbroken that this has been abandoned. One of my favorite crossovers. I hope you find the energy to work on it sometime soon!
2/6 c8 Die author
Trash af
Trash af
1/21 c37 Guest
Most likely the author died. C'est la vie.
Most likely the author died. C'est la vie.
1/9 c37 Guest
I can only hope to see a new update, so long since it’s last one, but hope I will.
I can only hope to see a new update, so long since it’s last one, but hope I will.
1/6 c16 Guest
I’m convinced harry succeeded; massive pools of water are how you defeat the balrog in shadow of Mordor too
I’m convinced harry succeeded; massive pools of water are how you defeat the balrog in shadow of Mordor too
1/2 c37 lkjnhbg
I hope this gets continued or someone adopts it, however difficult that would be
I hope this gets continued or someone adopts it, however difficult that would be
12/7/2024 c37 1RangerSilverstorm
A great story, I hope you return to it someday. Its a tragedy worthy of song should it never be finished. Thank you for writing whats here.
1RangerSilverstormA great story, I hope you return to it someday. Its a tragedy worthy of song should it never be finished. Thank you for writing whats here.
12/4/2024 c37 1bleachorange
A good story. I hope you have time for more chapters in the future to complete the tale.
1bleachorangeA good story. I hope you have time for more chapters in the future to complete the tale.
12/3/2024 c11 bleachorange
Its been a good story so far. I think my main struggles have been with the names in some of the languages used. They are not as memorable in their strangeness, Tolkien though they may be.
Its been a good story so far. I think my main struggles have been with the names in some of the languages used. They are not as memorable in their strangeness, Tolkien though they may be.