for The Shadow of Angmar7/25/2024 c37 Guest
Welp looks like this got dropped and that isn't that sad of a thing. This story has been utter garbage, the writer has made Harry potter a oxygen wasting useless retarded fuck with almost 0 character growth despite having written 37 chapters that span numerous decades, DECADES, and yet Harry potter is still a pathetic little bitch after all that time. Makes the story seem like nothing but a waste if time but the time you get to the end of what's been written leaving only the thought of what the fuck was the point.
Welp looks like this got dropped and that isn't that sad of a thing. This story has been utter garbage, the writer has made Harry potter a oxygen wasting useless retarded fuck with almost 0 character growth despite having written 37 chapters that span numerous decades, DECADES, and yet Harry potter is still a pathetic little bitch after all that time. Makes the story seem like nothing but a waste if time but the time you get to the end of what's been written leaving only the thought of what the fuck was the point.
7/25/2024 c15 Guest
Sooo is Harry going to have any actual character growth or magic because so far we've had 15 chapters of Harry being a pathetic worthless fucking retarded bitch who apparently is incapable of learning to not be a fucktard and is uselss because he can't actually do any magic.
Sooo is Harry going to have any actual character growth or magic because so far we've had 15 chapters of Harry being a pathetic worthless fucking retarded bitch who apparently is incapable of learning to not be a fucktard and is uselss because he can't actually do any magic.
7/23/2024 c30 Guest
Just as a note here I guess, the author was definitely still alive a month ago as their Reddit account was active then. Some of the reviewers here questioning if the author died is maybe a smidgen too morbid
Onto the story. This chapter with the tree blooming is honestly even now the best fanfiction chapter that I can recall reading. Just for how well it just feels like it could have come straight from the source itself and being so uniquely impactful. But for what must be my fourth read through this whole story still holds up which is a testament to the writing.
Just as a note here I guess, the author was definitely still alive a month ago as their Reddit account was active then. Some of the reviewers here questioning if the author died is maybe a smidgen too morbid
Onto the story. This chapter with the tree blooming is honestly even now the best fanfiction chapter that I can recall reading. Just for how well it just feels like it could have come straight from the source itself and being so uniquely impactful. But for what must be my fourth read through this whole story still holds up which is a testament to the writing.
6/16/2024 c37 Guest
I remember reading in my youth, when my knowledge of Lotr came from the movies alone. There where so many confusing stuff I couldn't get past the 1st few chapters.
After seeing a video on youtube about the history of morgoth, my curiosity got the better of me.
I read the silmarilion, and it was like alice going down the rabbit hole: the fall of gondolin, Beren and luthien, Turin turamba, the book of lost tales, etc.
Now after reading this again and seeing how you weave the tales of Tolkiens legenderium with harry potter. It's truly fascinating, thank you for the great read. Your take on some of the characters was in someway true to themselves and not too far from how tolkien envisioned them. That can can only be because of good writing.
I remember reading in my youth, when my knowledge of Lotr came from the movies alone. There where so many confusing stuff I couldn't get past the 1st few chapters.
After seeing a video on youtube about the history of morgoth, my curiosity got the better of me.
I read the silmarilion, and it was like alice going down the rabbit hole: the fall of gondolin, Beren and luthien, Turin turamba, the book of lost tales, etc.
Now after reading this again and seeing how you weave the tales of Tolkiens legenderium with harry potter. It's truly fascinating, thank you for the great read. Your take on some of the characters was in someway true to themselves and not too far from how tolkien envisioned them. That can can only be because of good writing.
5/26/2024 c7 Gjfhdhfhdt
Overwhelming, not very entertaining, good writing of compound and formal sentences, good dialogue, but without substance, the narrative does not promise or promote hope but sadism. There are no epic moments and the only feeling the author seems to convey is pity for his protagonist who is Harry Potter in name only. In short, this is a waste of time. It does not fulfil its aim to entertain. A pity .
Overwhelming, not very entertaining, good writing of compound and formal sentences, good dialogue, but without substance, the narrative does not promise or promote hope but sadism. There are no epic moments and the only feeling the author seems to convey is pity for his protagonist who is Harry Potter in name only. In short, this is a waste of time. It does not fulfil its aim to entertain. A pity .
5/21/2024 c37 GwynCoram
After all these years I still drop in from time to time to check if it doesn't get an update, however vain my hope always turns to be.
They are not writing a stories like this one anymore...
Hopefully, you are doing alright mr. Author
After all these years I still drop in from time to time to check if it doesn't get an update, however vain my hope always turns to be.
They are not writing a stories like this one anymore...
Hopefully, you are doing alright mr. Author
5/20/2024 c37 Guest
This is such a delight to read! I found your story about a week ago and have been reading straight through. I hope you are still working on this as I would absolutely love to read more thank you for your great mind and amazing talentī¸
This is such a delight to read! I found your story about a week ago and have been reading straight through. I hope you are still working on this as I would absolutely love to read more thank you for your great mind and amazing talentī¸
4/25/2024 c37 DedicatedReader2020
hey mate long time fan of the story, hope all is well. the scenes with the tree underground were my favorite
hey mate long time fan of the story, hope all is well. the scenes with the tree underground were my favorite
4/15/2024 c37 
2rufous
I hope you will continue writing this story. I love the twist on magic you use and direction you are taking it in.
2rufousI hope you will continue writing this story. I love the twist on magic you use and direction you are taking it in.
4/6/2024 c37 Argos
Hi dear author!
Hoppe you are doing well!
I remembered this story after a long time and came to see if there was any update.
Is this abandoned? I really wish you have not given up on this.
Hopefully waiting,
Argos
Hi dear author!
Hoppe you are doing well!
I remembered this story after a long time and came to see if there was any update.
Is this abandoned? I really wish you have not given up on this.
Hopefully waiting,
Argos
4/6/2024 c8 1Skull Crimes
this type of writing feels a little to flowery for Harry, he is learning a new language and yet the way it is written makes you feel like he has been speaking it his whole life, also they don't fit what a teenager who has just been tortured would sound like. But anyway good work notheless
1Skull Crimesthis type of writing feels a little to flowery for Harry, he is learning a new language and yet the way it is written makes you feel like he has been speaking it his whole life, also they don't fit what a teenager who has just been tortured would sound like. But anyway good work notheless
3/22/2024 c37 0richierich0
Ha! I somehow missed these last two chapters before the three-year gap and just assumed I'd read everything posted. I have just re-read your fantastic story again and discovered this wonderful conclusion to your story's second arc. Best LOTR fanfiction that I have ever read. Thanks so much!
Ha! I somehow missed these last two chapters before the three-year gap and just assumed I'd read everything posted. I have just re-read your fantastic story again and discovered this wonderful conclusion to your story's second arc. Best LOTR fanfiction that I have ever read. Thanks so much!