
11/14/2015 c7 Guest
Not a bad update
Not a bad update
11/14/2015 c7
2zolydck
P.S Well done, What and interesting way to have him secure Ginny's loyalty.
I also love intelligent uses for spells (so well done on that front).
I assume Alexandra black is next? Anyways keep up the great work.

P.S Well done, What and interesting way to have him secure Ginny's loyalty.
I also love intelligent uses for spells (so well done on that front).
I assume Alexandra black is next? Anyways keep up the great work.
11/14/2015 c7
7bigfan22
Mice chapter. With Ginny and Hermione now loyal to Harry as apposed to John, things are going to be crazy once everyone actually gets to Hogwarts. Can't wait for that to happen. Great job and I hope we get another update soon.

Mice chapter. With Ginny and Hermione now loyal to Harry as apposed to John, things are going to be crazy once everyone actually gets to Hogwarts. Can't wait for that to happen. Great job and I hope we get another update soon.
11/14/2015 c7
2lynxreader
a good story, but you could do with a beta reader to help with spelling and grammar issues. including, but not necessarily limited to:
an "isle" is a small island. an "aisle" is a narrow space left clear for walking through. they're pronounced the same, but spelled differently.
if you aren't clear on the difference between "the ground" and "a floor", allow me to come visit your house. i'll wear my muddy, filthy boots as i tromp all through your living room, *just to make the point*.
the only time you have a "floor" outdoors is when you're talking about a "forest floor", and in that case you need to say so explicitly.
honestly, i do not know why this particular error is becoming so very common among younger writers these days. do you kids never take your boots off?
"parameter" and "perimeter" are pronounced ALMOST the same, but mean very different things. though i'm not sure this is actually wrong in this chapter, since i can well imagine a "parameter ward" might be a thing in your story too.
and Ginny was a horrible waste of a potentially great character on JKR's behalf. i mean, there's just so much you could do with her in canon! she went from stammering fangirl with her elbow in the butter to leading lady married to the hero, so there's a coming-of-age story there; she went from mind control victim near death to someone who apparently figured big in the DA in Hogwarts during the Snape/Carrows era, so there's overcoming great struggles and young heroism there; there's all the family connections of a spoiled only daughter of a woman who apparently wanted a daughter BADLY as she grows up through her brothers flying the coop and getting married, plus getting her own connections outside the family, so there's a social-network tale too; there's just so very much Ginny Weasley COULD have been, that Rowling never showed us.
i really think if she'd been a better fleshed out character in canon, people wouldn't have taken it so badly that she ended up with Harry in the end. the problem with that pairing was mostly, i think, that she came out of nowhere - this never-detailed, never-explained, two-dimensional background character suddenly and for no reason popping onto centre stage. people want the harmony pairing (and i do too, i confess) because Hermione was the female character who got all the details and explanation AS a character, so she seemed like she *deserved* to be the leading lady. but if Ginny had got half of that, i think she easily could have been, too.

a good story, but you could do with a beta reader to help with spelling and grammar issues. including, but not necessarily limited to:
an "isle" is a small island. an "aisle" is a narrow space left clear for walking through. they're pronounced the same, but spelled differently.
if you aren't clear on the difference between "the ground" and "a floor", allow me to come visit your house. i'll wear my muddy, filthy boots as i tromp all through your living room, *just to make the point*.
the only time you have a "floor" outdoors is when you're talking about a "forest floor", and in that case you need to say so explicitly.
honestly, i do not know why this particular error is becoming so very common among younger writers these days. do you kids never take your boots off?
"parameter" and "perimeter" are pronounced ALMOST the same, but mean very different things. though i'm not sure this is actually wrong in this chapter, since i can well imagine a "parameter ward" might be a thing in your story too.
and Ginny was a horrible waste of a potentially great character on JKR's behalf. i mean, there's just so much you could do with her in canon! she went from stammering fangirl with her elbow in the butter to leading lady married to the hero, so there's a coming-of-age story there; she went from mind control victim near death to someone who apparently figured big in the DA in Hogwarts during the Snape/Carrows era, so there's overcoming great struggles and young heroism there; there's all the family connections of a spoiled only daughter of a woman who apparently wanted a daughter BADLY as she grows up through her brothers flying the coop and getting married, plus getting her own connections outside the family, so there's a social-network tale too; there's just so very much Ginny Weasley COULD have been, that Rowling never showed us.
i really think if she'd been a better fleshed out character in canon, people wouldn't have taken it so badly that she ended up with Harry in the end. the problem with that pairing was mostly, i think, that she came out of nowhere - this never-detailed, never-explained, two-dimensional background character suddenly and for no reason popping onto centre stage. people want the harmony pairing (and i do too, i confess) because Hermione was the female character who got all the details and explanation AS a character, so she seemed like she *deserved* to be the leading lady. but if Ginny had got half of that, i think she easily could have been, too.
11/12/2015 c6 jsiemens365
I can honestly say this is one of the first stories to truly catch my attention in several years, I do enjoy seeing so many elements (one might say cliches) of fanfiction being in used in what has, thus far, been quite tasteful. And thoughtful with regards to the possibilities. I distinctly enjoy the opportunities being used as far as aging potions, and the details that follow, such as the last details Ms Granger gives, off hormonal imbalance, and so forth. and I am quite fascinated by how you chose to introduce her to magic, through alice-in-wonderland disguised as a maths lesson. I look forward to seeing how this continues.
I can honestly say this is one of the first stories to truly catch my attention in several years, I do enjoy seeing so many elements (one might say cliches) of fanfiction being in used in what has, thus far, been quite tasteful. And thoughtful with regards to the possibilities. I distinctly enjoy the opportunities being used as far as aging potions, and the details that follow, such as the last details Ms Granger gives, off hormonal imbalance, and so forth. and I am quite fascinated by how you chose to introduce her to magic, through alice-in-wonderland disguised as a maths lesson. I look forward to seeing how this continues.
11/12/2015 c1 Salathi
can't wait for some revenge lol. I love the "wrong-boy-who-lived" stories, can't wait for more
can't wait for some revenge lol. I love the "wrong-boy-who-lived" stories, can't wait for more