for The Boy Who Lived, The Brightest Witch and The Boy Who Wasn't1/2 c37 Spinalittleglow
I hope you come back to this story one day! I would love to see more of it and how this version of events develop
I hope you come back to this story one day! I would love to see more of it and how this version of events develop
11/11/2024 c37 
8Judy.Laura.L
Please continue this! It’s so entertaining and fulfilling I had a hard time putting it down. Harry and Hermione’s relationship seems so much healthier and I’m glad Neville has friends who are there for him, watch his back, and inspire more confidence within him. Sirius is finally living a good life as a free man, and be there for Harry. Both of them finally finding the family and happiness they so deserve. Hermione’s mission to freeing the elves is being taken seriously and she’s already on her way to becoming the future minister of magic by taking on the higher ups and fighting injustice. I can go on and on about everything I love about this story but I’d run out of room I just want to let you know how much I enjoy this story and hope to see it continued.
8Judy.Laura.LPlease continue this! It’s so entertaining and fulfilling I had a hard time putting it down. Harry and Hermione’s relationship seems so much healthier and I’m glad Neville has friends who are there for him, watch his back, and inspire more confidence within him. Sirius is finally living a good life as a free man, and be there for Harry. Both of them finally finding the family and happiness they so deserve. Hermione’s mission to freeing the elves is being taken seriously and she’s already on her way to becoming the future minister of magic by taking on the higher ups and fighting injustice. I can go on and on about everything I love about this story but I’d run out of room I just want to let you know how much I enjoy this story and hope to see it continued.
11/2/2024 c37 Guest
Please continue writing this series I know it’s only been a year but you’re so talented this is exactly how it should have been written and if I don’t know what happens next I think I might die
Please continue writing this series I know it’s only been a year but you’re so talented this is exactly how it should have been written and if I don’t know what happens next I think I might die
10/28/2024 c4 29duj
I think you're wrong about the Shack trick. Canon doesn't supply much in the way of evidence, but would you trust a deadly Secret - your family's *lives* - to someone who'd previously blabbed another friend's life-changing secret? You'd have to be barking mad, wouldn't you? But James trusted Sirius. Why?
I say that Snape was right. James was in on the Shrieking Shack thing, but he didn't see it as betraying a friend because Lupin was in on it too, and Peter. *All* the Marauders were in on it. If Snape caught them illegally changing into Animagi and freeing a 5X dangerous creature, would they be able to continue doing that every full moon?
Think about it. Lupin's motive to get Snape off their trail was even stronger than the other Marauders' motive. *They* could romp as Animagi any day of the week, but he could only join them on full moons.
Backstory:
We know the Marauders weren't worried about the lycanthropy issue getting out, because in Snape's Worst Memory we saw them cracking jokes about it loudly enough to figure in Snape's memory, even though there was a crowd of students between him and them. It's only when someone mentions "running around every month" that they clam up.
(Lycanthropy was the school's secret too, so why should they worry? They knew Dumbledore would threaten into silence anyone who found out.)
But their unregistered Animagus identities and their full moon romps around the neighbourhood with a 5X dangerous creature were secrets they *couldn't* trust to Dumbledore, because what if he made them stop?
So they needed to get Snape off their tail. (Heaven knows nobody else was likely to find out.) Only Sirius took it a step too far, trying to get Snape Turned or injured - or killed - and when he fessed up to James, James knew he had to Abort Abort for their own good.
Like I said, think about it...
29dujI think you're wrong about the Shack trick. Canon doesn't supply much in the way of evidence, but would you trust a deadly Secret - your family's *lives* - to someone who'd previously blabbed another friend's life-changing secret? You'd have to be barking mad, wouldn't you? But James trusted Sirius. Why?
I say that Snape was right. James was in on the Shrieking Shack thing, but he didn't see it as betraying a friend because Lupin was in on it too, and Peter. *All* the Marauders were in on it. If Snape caught them illegally changing into Animagi and freeing a 5X dangerous creature, would they be able to continue doing that every full moon?
Think about it. Lupin's motive to get Snape off their trail was even stronger than the other Marauders' motive. *They* could romp as Animagi any day of the week, but he could only join them on full moons.
Backstory:
We know the Marauders weren't worried about the lycanthropy issue getting out, because in Snape's Worst Memory we saw them cracking jokes about it loudly enough to figure in Snape's memory, even though there was a crowd of students between him and them. It's only when someone mentions "running around every month" that they clam up.
(Lycanthropy was the school's secret too, so why should they worry? They knew Dumbledore would threaten into silence anyone who found out.)
But their unregistered Animagus identities and their full moon romps around the neighbourhood with a 5X dangerous creature were secrets they *couldn't* trust to Dumbledore, because what if he made them stop?
So they needed to get Snape off their tail. (Heaven knows nobody else was likely to find out.) Only Sirius took it a step too far, trying to get Snape Turned or injured - or killed - and when he fessed up to James, James knew he had to Abort Abort for their own good.
Like I said, think about it...
9/21/2024 c37 Guest
Amazing story; I really enjoyed how close Harry and Hermione became, and Neville is an interesting addition. I appreciate how they let Ron have another chance and he has been a good friend lately but it’s not the same dynamic.
I hope this story hasn’t been abandoned!
Amazing story; I really enjoyed how close Harry and Hermione became, and Neville is an interesting addition. I appreciate how they let Ron have another chance and he has been a good friend lately but it’s not the same dynamic.
I hope this story hasn’t been abandoned!
7/30/2024 c1 2SpSt
oh man, I thought this story updated a few weeks ago, but i misread the year. you're writing an excellent book here and I hope you continuea
2SpStoh man, I thought this story updated a few weeks ago, but i misread the year. you're writing an excellent book here and I hope you continuea
7/25/2024 c37 Guest
Enjoying every word of your story.
Enjoying every word of your story.