11/29 c34 1Kyria Greene
The way you portray Harry and Luna’s relationship is gorgeous. James and his regret is heart rending. Thank you for such a beautiful story.
The way you portray Harry and Luna’s relationship is gorgeous. James and his regret is heart rending. Thank you for such a beautiful story.
11/20 c6 3LordHadesinTartarus
So two major problems. A person is an obscurial; the obscurus is the parasitic form that individual's magic takes. A young magical only becomes an obscurial if they have been actively suppressing their magic - there's no hint of that in canon or in this fic. Trauma is not enough, they have to be actually resisting and resenting their own nature as magical. If you're trying to mirror Ariana Dumbledore here - it doesn't make sense; she lost control of her magic and subsequently became afraid of her own magical nature turning that uncontrolled power inward.
So two major problems. A person is an obscurial; the obscurus is the parasitic form that individual's magic takes. A young magical only becomes an obscurial if they have been actively suppressing their magic - there's no hint of that in canon or in this fic. Trauma is not enough, they have to be actually resisting and resenting their own nature as magical. If you're trying to mirror Ariana Dumbledore here - it doesn't make sense; she lost control of her magic and subsequently became afraid of her own magical nature turning that uncontrolled power inward.
11/17 c34 Sheelahdog
Wow! I was not expecting that! Two taken out but also Dumbles. That does not square up. But also, go Andy!
Wow! I was not expecting that! Two taken out but also Dumbles. That does not square up. But also, go Andy!
11/17 c34 aesir21
Noble way to go out that way. Unfortunately yet another loss for Harry to experience
Noble way to go out that way. Unfortunately yet another loss for Harry to experience
11/12 c34 6MissyMoeDoe
OH come on! You can not leave it like this. Please with tiny little pecan pies and cheesecakes on top? This is such a great story. Thank you for putting it out here for us to enjoy!
OH come on! You can not leave it like this. Please with tiny little pecan pies and cheesecakes on top? This is such a great story. Thank you for putting it out here for us to enjoy!
11/10 c9 6MissyMoeDoe
I absolutely LOVE the interaction between Harry and the different animals. I hope to see more of it. Every time you put out a new chapter I go back through the story and hit the conversations just so that I remember for when I get to the new stuff. I never get tired of rereading it. Thank you!
I absolutely LOVE the interaction between Harry and the different animals. I hope to see more of it. Every time you put out a new chapter I go back through the story and hit the conversations just so that I remember for when I get to the new stuff. I never get tired of rereading it. Thank you!
11/6 c34 HowardAmos
Thoughts: Good story, though rather troubling. Not a good place to stop, but I don't think you've stopped here.
Demi-Dragons: All out of those. Aren't they found in primary schools?
Feedback: Keep up the good work!
Thoughts: Good story, though rather troubling. Not a good place to stop, but I don't think you've stopped here.
Demi-Dragons: All out of those. Aren't they found in primary schools?
Feedback: Keep up the good work!
11/3 c34 2trekkifulron
thoughtsoh wow a bit hash there, Abe...
demi-dragonhow about Ms. Pryde's friend Lockheed?
feedbackA 5* review but could use more Hedwig
thoughtsoh wow a bit hash there, Abe...
demi-dragonhow about Ms. Pryde's friend Lockheed?
feedbackA 5* review but could use more Hedwig
11/2 c1 4Saifo
great, and don't listen to those don't like angst. Yours is one of the few stories here that I like in the whole site
great, and don't listen to those don't like angst. Yours is one of the few stories here that I like in the whole site
10/31 c34 3ObsessedWithHPFanFic
Good chapter and rather amazing that Albus didn't take Jr. seriously. Thanks for sharing!
Good chapter and rather amazing that Albus didn't take Jr. seriously. Thanks for sharing!