for A Keen Observer2/28 c31 Tonks7777777
LOVE THIS! I think ive read it 3 times now, and it was one of the first if not the first fan fic i ever read! And now years later after reading 600 fics i still have this one fresh in my mind. Thank you so much for this beautiful story! To me, this is the canon back story of the Black sisters. <3
LOVE THIS! I think ive read it 3 times now, and it was one of the first if not the first fan fic i ever read! And now years later after reading 600 fics i still have this one fresh in my mind. Thank you so much for this beautiful story! To me, this is the canon back story of the Black sisters. <3
11/25/2024 c31 RoseM
Hello,
I just wanted to say that this fanfiction has been one of my favourites for a good long decade, and it’s always a delight to read it and rediscover it all over again. You’ve breathed life into these characters who are so enjoyable to follow and come back to. What a beautiful read- thank you so much!
Hello,
I just wanted to say that this fanfiction has been one of my favourites for a good long decade, and it’s always a delight to read it and rediscover it all over again. You’ve breathed life into these characters who are so enjoyable to follow and come back to. What a beautiful read- thank you so much!
5/26/2024 c31 EverThePessimist
Lovely. I love how this Andromeda wasn’t nice from the start and had to unlearn the prejudice. I love how close her and Bella were. It hurts so much that they'll never get that again. Especially if we consider that this goes the way of canon and Bella kills Ted and Dora.
Lovely. I love how this Andromeda wasn’t nice from the start and had to unlearn the prejudice. I love how close her and Bella were. It hurts so much that they'll never get that again. Especially if we consider that this goes the way of canon and Bella kills Ted and Dora.
6/19/2023 c31 hcavoliveira
Just re-read the books after nearly a decade, and it left me with a thirst for more of this universe, so I decided to dive into fanfics. Yours was the first I ever read, and boy oh boy, did you set the bar high!
Just re-read the books after nearly a decade, and it left me with a thirst for more of this universe, so I decided to dive into fanfics. Yours was the first I ever read, and boy oh boy, did you set the bar high!
6/14/2023 c31 bectouzel1
What an amazing insight into Andromeda Black’s life - you wrote her and her sisters so well. And Ted was so sweet!
What an amazing insight into Andromeda Black’s life - you wrote her and her sisters so well. And Ted was so sweet!
3/8/2023 c31 Guest
ahhh this fic is soo good. love andy and ted and bellatrix too. you didn’t make her intp a saint? shes just as bad as in the books but you let us know that she isnt a monster to everyone, that she even is capable of loving someone as fiercely as she loves her sisters.
ahhh this fic is soo good. love andy and ted and bellatrix too. you didn’t make her intp a saint? shes just as bad as in the books but you let us know that she isnt a monster to everyone, that she even is capable of loving someone as fiercely as she loves her sisters.
2/28/2023 c31 
380Dani H. Danvers
This story is incredible. I have loved every chapter. You write so well.
380Dani H. DanversThis story is incredible. I have loved every chapter. You write so well.
11/18/2021 c31 2strawberryella
I know you probably don’t follow your reviews on this story anymore but I just wanted to say that I absolutely love it. I read it first over a decade ago and just reread it for the first time. Thank you xxx
2strawberryellaI know you probably don’t follow your reviews on this story anymore but I just wanted to say that I absolutely love it. I read it first over a decade ago and just reread it for the first time. Thank you xxx
7/3/2021 c1 CocoaPuff1347
Wow. I’ve never read this ship and to say that I liked this fanfic would be an understatement.
The way that Andromeda, Bellatrix, and Narcissa’s childhoods were described built a world throughout the fic and made the characters more 3 dimensional.
I loved it
Wow. I’ve never read this ship and to say that I liked this fanfic would be an understatement.
The way that Andromeda, Bellatrix, and Narcissa’s childhoods were described built a world throughout the fic and made the characters more 3 dimensional.
I loved it
5/16/2021 c3 DarkChocolateLord
I love how we see the political tensions growing even now, and the contrast between the adults talking about war and politics and the kids being kids is perfect. And Ted and the Christmas card! Heck yes.
I love how we see the political tensions growing even now, and the contrast between the adults talking about war and politics and the kids being kids is perfect. And Ted and the Christmas card! Heck yes.