for Silence9/10/2018 c1 gumper
Oh wow - so poignant and sad...
I can’t help but wonder about the timing - shortly after Bonnie’s death or many years into the future. I’m guessing the latter (given her lack of anger) which makes it feel even more heartbreaking to me for some reason.
Very well done.
Oh wow - so poignant and sad...
I can’t help but wonder about the timing - shortly after Bonnie’s death or many years into the future. I’m guessing the latter (given her lack of anger) which makes it feel even more heartbreaking to me for some reason.
Very well done.
11/27/2011 c1 
3Tourmaline Shine
A terrific heartbreaker. Poor Scarlett. Bonnie, Rhett, and Mr. Butler! This makes the tragedy seem all the sadder.
3Tourmaline ShineA terrific heartbreaker. Poor Scarlett. Bonnie, Rhett, and Mr. Butler! This makes the tragedy seem all the sadder.
8/16/2008 c1 10sohhkb
Great recollection piece. Too bad it had to be in first person, I'm just not a fan of first person in GWTW fics. For the first couple of sentences I thought this was Rhett's memory but was pleasantly surprised when I realized (a bit too late, because she'd already called herself "mother" more than once) that this piece was from Scarlett's perspective. How fun to be in a writing group!
10sohhkbGreat recollection piece. Too bad it had to be in first person, I'm just not a fan of first person in GWTW fics. For the first couple of sentences I thought this was Rhett's memory but was pleasantly surprised when I realized (a bit too late, because she'd already called herself "mother" more than once) that this piece was from Scarlett's perspective. How fun to be in a writing group!
8/15/2008 c1 7Scarlett Jaimie
Oh my God, how beautiful. I don't know how you faced up to writing that, I read that you are a mother, so this must have taken some courage. I hope I will have your nerve to write something like that some day. And I like your message; don't waist a minute, it is so precious. So I am turning of this PC and going to enjoy a day with my two little girls. Thanks!
7Scarlett JaimieOh my God, how beautiful. I don't know how you faced up to writing that, I read that you are a mother, so this must have taken some courage. I hope I will have your nerve to write something like that some day. And I like your message; don't waist a minute, it is so precious. So I am turning of this PC and going to enjoy a day with my two little girls. Thanks!
8/13/2008 c1 5iris fibonacci
Very poignant and sad. It's a shame that Scarlett never seemed to appreciate the people she loved best (and who loved her) before she lost them.
5iris fibonacciVery poignant and sad. It's a shame that Scarlett never seemed to appreciate the people she loved best (and who loved her) before she lost them.
8/12/2008 c1 queenie11
It's beautiful...I felt my heart go cold at the last line. You can truly touch people with your writing. Anyone who has lost someone can connect with this piece.
It's beautiful...I felt my heart go cold at the last line. You can truly touch people with your writing. Anyone who has lost someone can connect with this piece.
8/12/2008 c1 45Abandoned Account 4815162342
That was a sad and sweet story and I liked reading it. Do you get your challenges from on-line? I'd like to try one of them sometime! :)
45Abandoned Account 4815162342That was a sad and sweet story and I liked reading it. Do you get your challenges from on-line? I'd like to try one of them sometime! :)
8/12/2008 c1 50PrincessAlica
You seriously made me cry.
What a fantastic excersise. I'm so glad that that is what you do for fun!
50PrincessAlicaYou seriously made me cry.
What a fantastic excersise. I'm so glad that that is what you do for fun!
8/12/2008 c1 18Mad Steph
This was really heartbreaking ... I actually had to turn off iTunes, because I thought it deserved to be read in total silence.
Probably one of the most beautiful and well written story I have ever read in Gone with the Wind fanfiction.
18Mad StephThis was really heartbreaking ... I actually had to turn off iTunes, because I thought it deserved to be read in total silence.
Probably one of the most beautiful and well written story I have ever read in Gone with the Wind fanfiction.
8/12/2008 c1 georgia1206
I enjoyed this! As a mother I know we can both relate to Scarlett and her regrets. Sometimes we all need a little more patience. Good Job. FYI Can't wait for updates to your other stories. Love them both!
I enjoyed this! As a mother I know we can both relate to Scarlett and her regrets. Sometimes we all need a little more patience. Good Job. FYI Can't wait for updates to your other stories. Love them both!