for Mirror, Mirror9/10/2013 c47 
13Break This Spell626
Holy shit! Excuse my language but sometimes it's necessary and this is one of those times. That was amazing!
13Break This Spell626Holy shit! Excuse my language but sometimes it's necessary and this is one of those times. That was amazing!
9/2/2013 c45 115percychased
This was really wonderful - you certainly have a way with words. I loved the way this fic flowed, and the description is just wonderful! Good job!
115percychasedThis was really wonderful - you certainly have a way with words. I loved the way this fic flowed, and the description is just wonderful! Good job!
8/17/2013 c47 639yellow 14
Painfully sharp and a good look at why Petunia was so twisted. Keep updating
639yellow 14Painfully sharp and a good look at why Petunia was so twisted. Keep updating
8/8/2013 c46 13Break This Spell626
Congratulations you made me cry! Thays really hard to do, by the way. Amazjng chapter.
13Break This Spell626Congratulations you made me cry! Thays really hard to do, by the way. Amazjng chapter.
7/29/2013 c45 37of archival interest only
Oh, poor Minerva :( It's so sad, how much she's lost in love... I loved how you used the mirror to show how she'd changed throughout her years, from Macgregor to Elphinstone to a final hope for peace. And again, that final paragraph was really something—you really broke my heart. Well done!
37of archival interest onlyOh, poor Minerva :( It's so sad, how much she's lost in love... I loved how you used the mirror to show how she'd changed throughout her years, from Macgregor to Elphinstone to a final hope for peace. And again, that final paragraph was really something—you really broke my heart. Well done!
7/29/2013 c45 88alverixorcustransfrogamorphus
I loved this. It provided so much insight into McGonagall, a character that we don't get to see much of at all during the series, unless she's getting Harry into trouble or whatever. I love how you've given her a life outside hogwarts and delved so deep into her emotions. It really connects the reader to the story and draws them in. I also love how her most desperate desires change over time. I really liked that. Great job!
DFTBA
Nayla xx
88alverixorcustransfrogamorphusI loved this. It provided so much insight into McGonagall, a character that we don't get to see much of at all during the series, unless she's getting Harry into trouble or whatever. I love how you've given her a life outside hogwarts and delved so deep into her emotions. It really connects the reader to the story and draws them in. I also love how her most desperate desires change over time. I really liked that. Great job!
DFTBA
Nayla xx
7/29/2013 c45 59APhoenixRising
Ooh, I love this! It's so unique.
To be honest I've never read about Minerva before, so this was very enjoyable. I love the back story that she has in this too. It really does make her what she is in the canon series. Tough but with a big heart, really.
I couldn't find any mistakes so well done on that!
Overall, a really nice story!
59APhoenixRisingOoh, I love this! It's so unique.
To be honest I've never read about Minerva before, so this was very enjoyable. I love the back story that she has in this too. It really does make her what she is in the canon series. Tough but with a big heart, really.
I couldn't find any mistakes so well done on that!
Overall, a really nice story!
7/28/2013 c45 20pottergoose
Oh my gosh! You wrote about my favorite thing that was provided on pottermore! The tragic story of Dougal and McGonagall really tore at my heart when I read it on pottermore, and I think you depicted what Minerva would most likely have seen in the mirror of erised perfectly. Thank you for this! That really made my day!
20pottergooseOh my gosh! You wrote about my favorite thing that was provided on pottermore! The tragic story of Dougal and McGonagall really tore at my heart when I read it on pottermore, and I think you depicted what Minerva would most likely have seen in the mirror of erised perfectly. Thank you for this! That really made my day!
7/27/2013 c45 26deerlypadfoot
I'd read a bit about McGonagall on Pottermore and her two-so husbands, but you brought a brilliant light to it and the narrative style was somehow still very personal and touching. I love the idea of Minerva looking into the Mirror of Erised and seeing different men at different points in her life; it's a very powerful, if not a bit sad. You highlighted that grief exceptionally well in few words, and overall it was quite fantastically written.
26deerlypadfootI'd read a bit about McGonagall on Pottermore and her two-so husbands, but you brought a brilliant light to it and the narrative style was somehow still very personal and touching. I love the idea of Minerva looking into the Mirror of Erised and seeing different men at different points in her life; it's a very powerful, if not a bit sad. You highlighted that grief exceptionally well in few words, and overall it was quite fantastically written.
7/23/2013 c45 615articcat621
Oh my gosh, honestly, this was so beautiful! Oh my, I can’t even help the tears!
Minerva is one of my favorite characters, and this was truly beautiful. I can’t even formulate words right now. The way you formulated her past with the Mirror was just so perfectly. Honestly, this was so good.
615articcat621Oh my gosh, honestly, this was so beautiful! Oh my, I can’t even help the tears!
Minerva is one of my favorite characters, and this was truly beautiful. I can’t even formulate words right now. The way you formulated her past with the Mirror was just so perfectly. Honestly, this was so good.
7/18/2013 c45 34Montley
I really really loved this!
It was a wonderful study of Minerva's life through the mirror and what she saw in it at different ages. I loved how you talked of her loves and her past.
It was a truly brilliant story, and I really loved it, you captured Minerva beautifully throughout, and I have no criticisms at all. There were no mistakes. A flawless story!
Fantastic work!
34MontleyI really really loved this!
It was a wonderful study of Minerva's life through the mirror and what she saw in it at different ages. I loved how you talked of her loves and her past.
It was a truly brilliant story, and I really loved it, you captured Minerva beautifully throughout, and I have no criticisms at all. There were no mistakes. A flawless story!
Fantastic work!