for Till Death12/9/2023 c8 Marm
You are (again) absolutely nailing it—you have Kay’s style down perfectly. This is exactly as you said, the missing chapters. But way too short. You’ve got Erik’s unpredictable sudden humor, the bonkers eruption of it: “Wherever will we get enough masks for all of them?” Chef’s kiss. It’s completely perfect. How. Lunatic, again.
You are (again) absolutely nailing it—you have Kay’s style down perfectly. This is exactly as you said, the missing chapters. But way too short. You’ve got Erik’s unpredictable sudden humor, the bonkers eruption of it: “Wherever will we get enough masks for all of them?” Chef’s kiss. It’s completely perfect. How. Lunatic, again.
11/11/2022 c11 yimello
Whelp, that was almost physically painful. I avoid rereading the Kay novel because it always makes me bawl like a baby... but now I'm crying anyway - full on gross-sobbing crying, not delicate a-few-tears crying.
On a less depressing note, Erik's characterization was really on point, and I loved the little moments of sarcastic humor you gave him. Very true to the Kay novel.
Whelp, that was almost physically painful. I avoid rereading the Kay novel because it always makes me bawl like a baby... but now I'm crying anyway - full on gross-sobbing crying, not delicate a-few-tears crying.
On a less depressing note, Erik's characterization was really on point, and I loved the little moments of sarcastic humor you gave him. Very true to the Kay novel.
10/22/2022 c9 Guest
Aww :( No where near enough time for them. But still, better than Leroux or Kay ending for sure...thanks.
Teen543
Aww :( No where near enough time for them. But still, better than Leroux or Kay ending for sure...thanks.
Teen543
7/6/2021 c1 blubird2021
This story is really amazing. Your piece of Erik can fit into Kay's version seamlessly, and I love your Daroga. I'm off to check out your page.
This story is really amazing. Your piece of Erik can fit into Kay's version seamlessly, and I love your Daroga. I'm off to check out your page.
3/4/2021 c11 Eli Bee
You made me weep...
You made me weep...
2/22/2021 c11 
2Lucyole
A very beautiful and sweet story of course the end is sad but that is how it ended good work.
2LucyoleA very beautiful and sweet story of course the end is sad but that is how it ended good work.
12/29/2020 c11 82Starwatcher2018
Lovely. So happy you posted the link on tumblr. The past never truly dies, does it?
82Starwatcher2018Lovely. So happy you posted the link on tumblr. The past never truly dies, does it?
9/12/2020 c1 2Aphaea21
Beautiful. Just beautiful. Made me sob! A perfect match to Susan Kay's style. Quite tempted to print your story out to stick into the relevant part of my copy of the book! Excellent story - thank you.
2Aphaea21Beautiful. Just beautiful. Made me sob! A perfect match to Susan Kay's style. Quite tempted to print your story out to stick into the relevant part of my copy of the book! Excellent story - thank you.
8/15/2020 c11 11Batty Dings
So, I favorited this back in May and for some reason I did not review it. That is a gross failure on my part.
This story absolutely broke my heart. It's the best kind of happy/tragic ending. Terribly bittersweet, but it gives the reader just what they always wanted from Kay's ending. Just a bit more closure.
It was so well written and obviously brought me to tears.
11Batty DingsSo, I favorited this back in May and for some reason I did not review it. That is a gross failure on my part.
This story absolutely broke my heart. It's the best kind of happy/tragic ending. Terribly bittersweet, but it gives the reader just what they always wanted from Kay's ending. Just a bit more closure.
It was so well written and obviously brought me to tears.
5/10/2020 c11 Guest
Just found this...it is so sadly beautiful. I have cried and cried. But the way you wrote the ending was so peaceful for everyone involved. This is a sad but beautiful with forgiveness and love. Christine is at peace now with Erik. They can watch over Raoul and Charles.
Just found this...it is so sadly beautiful. I have cried and cried. But the way you wrote the ending was so peaceful for everyone involved. This is a sad but beautiful with forgiveness and love. Christine is at peace now with Erik. They can watch over Raoul and Charles.
7/16/2018 c11 43Trinity Destler
You did it so perfectly. It's taken me years to gather the courage to read this and I'm glad I did even though I'm a weeping devastated mess, because you did it absolutely perfectly and this epilogue does help. It was necessary.
This is one of only two fics I've ever read that has affected me like actual Phantom always does. You captured them.
43Trinity DestlerYou did it so perfectly. It's taken me years to gather the courage to read this and I'm glad I did even though I'm a weeping devastated mess, because you did it absolutely perfectly and this epilogue does help. It was necessary.
This is one of only two fics I've ever read that has affected me like actual Phantom always does. You captured them.
7/16/2018 c4 Trinity Destler
Oh God, oh God, I can't read this, it's too good. I started sobbing in chapter 2 and haven't stopped.
Oh God, oh God, I can't read this, it's too good. I started sobbing in chapter 2 and haven't stopped.
2/10/2018 c11 Luca
God, you madre this sad! Madre me cry!
God, you madre this sad! Madre me cry!
4/2/2017 c11 3Kayleem127
Beautiful... I bawled my eyes out. Wasn't the smartest thing to do - reading this when it's that time of the month, lol. Either way, it was quite fantastic. I thank you for filling in the "missing" pieces.
3Kayleem127Beautiful... I bawled my eyes out. Wasn't the smartest thing to do - reading this when it's that time of the month, lol. Either way, it was quite fantastic. I thank you for filling in the "missing" pieces.
1/9/2017 c11 9Violonaire
I still didn't read Kay's Phantom but again, this romance story is well written!
9ViolonaireI still didn't read Kay's Phantom but again, this romance story is well written!