Gray looked into Natsu's eyes, like a gateway to their soul. Natsu was scared but Gray reassured him to calm him. Gray took his moistened index and middle fingers and slowly pushed them into his lovers tight pucker. Natsu moaned lightly underneath of him, slightly feeling some pain. But that soon eased over as pleasure overcame him and soon three fingers were added. After several minutes of the moaning and gasping, from his smaller lover, Gray decided that he was ready. He slicked his dick with lube as he slowly started to penetrate the tight hole. It was so tight but he didn't stop until he was all the way in. Natsu could feel his ass being stuffed. It hurt, but at the same time he could feel the pleasure start to come into play. After several minutes Natsu moved to signal that Gray could move. And he did just that. At first he started off slow, but soon enough Gray couldn't control himself. He was quickly pounding into Natsu's hole, hitting his prostate with every other thrust. Natsu moaned as he began to rock back onto Gray's cock. though it was painful before, Natsu was really enjoying it. Natsu let out a gasp and he told the older mage that he was about to come. So he flipped Natsu into the "doggy position" and pounded into him harder and faster than before. Gray could feel that soon he would be cumming. He moaned as he grabbed the fire mage's hips and thrusted into his lover one hard, final time. Natsu let out a lust filled yelp as he could feel gray's seed being shot deep within himself. After a few pants, and a few squeaks from his salamander as he pulled out, they laid down on the bed. Gray gave a contented sigh as he pulled the cover overtop of them. Before they fell asleep they said, "I love you" to one another, and a final blissful kiss.