12
Emily Prentiss, Your Friendly Matchmaker » by believer76
Emily introduces her friend Penny to Aaron Hotchner and both of them are immediately attracted to each other. Will Penelope continue to resist Aaron Hotchner charm? Or will she risk her very tender heart and take a chance? Alpha/Omega relationship. Please review!Criminal Minds, T, English, Romance & Adventure, chapters: 18, words: 85k+, favs: 43, follows: 23, updated: 5/8 published: 11/30/2019, [A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia] [E. Prentiss, Sean H.]
7 New Life, New Love » by believer76
Aaron Hotchner, vampire finds his mate in Penelope Garcia in the 1700's who is dying of smallpox that is killing the rest of her family. Will Penelope learn to trust her mate? Someone who turned her into a vampire without her agreement because she was dying of a disease that had no cure? Or will it end in tragedy?Criminal Minds, T, English, Romance & Supernatural, chapters: 13, words: 75k+, favs: 19, follows: 11, updated: 5/7 published: 3/10/2018, [A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia] [Jennifer J./JJ, D. Rossi]
A Day in the Life » by scoutmom22
AU Penelope Garcia loves her job and the people she works with… and she has fun. Aaron Hotchner is very good at his job… selectively appreciates the people he works with… and wants to learn to have fun. I own no characters or canon of Criminal Minds. Many thanks to those who created them. This fic is stand-alone, dedicated to FB page The Many Loves of Penelope Garcia.Criminal Minds, T, English, Romance & Friendship, chapters: 5, words: 6k+, favs: 8, follows: 9, updated: 10/1/2022 published: 9/29/2022, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia
8 Aftershave by Leigh59
Retiring because of a career ending injury, she is tricked into staying with someone from her distant past. Someone who she will admit to no one that she loves. Someone who feels the same, but is reluctant to admit it as well. For criminalmindsangel because she asked for this one.Criminal Minds, K+, English, Drama & Romance, words: 5k+, favs: 24, follows: 4, 6/26/2022, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia
If Dreams There Be by pandorabox82
Penelope unexpectedly finds Erin on the roof of their building, saying goodnight to her someone on the evening star, even as she's about to do the same. Will they both experience a Valentine's Day miracle?Criminal Minds, M, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 8k+, favs: 13, follows: 6, 3/18/2022, [P. Garcia, A. Hotchner/Hotch] Erin S., Alex B.
2 penelope in the field by MacGateFan
Penelope was asked to help while Emily was off because of the flu. She is sent with Hotch to follow up with a suspect. He is guilty but not for what they thought. She was amazed by the strength of her boss and a bit of her own as well.Criminal Minds, K+, English, Hurt/Comfort & Friendship, words: 1k+, favs: 6, follows: 2, 9/2/2021, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia
7 The Show Must Go On » by BookDragon2013
This is part 3 of my "If Things Were Different" Series. Here we find a Hotch in which Haley left him but didn't die, and Garcia is the favorite babysitter when Hotch is in a pickle schedule-wise. We will be starting out with Season 9 Episode 5 "Route 66." Fluff for now, smut later. Hope you enjoy! Pairing: Hotch & GarciaCriminal Minds, M, English, Romance, chapters: 3, words: 9k+, favs: 42, follows: 17, updated: 9/3/2020 published: 8/22/2020, [A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia]
4 Closure by Genevieve Darcy Granger
In the wake of her break-up with Kevin, Garcia is trying to get her groove back. Little does she know that there's been someone waiting under her nose all along for his chance at love with her.Criminal Minds, K+, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 3k+, favs: 45, follows: 15, 7/23/2020, [P. Garcia, A. Hotchner/Hotch] Kevin L.
15 A Good Man by Bren Gail
If she didn't know her husband as well as she did, she'd accuse him of having an affair with his subordinate. Haley Hotchner/Aaron Hotchner. Hints to a future Aaron Hotchner/Penelope Garcia.Criminal Minds, T, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 3k+, favs: 23, follows: 13, 12/28/2019, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia, Haley H.
4 How Sweet Our Future Will Be by pandorabox82
They've known each other for close to twenty years, but Penelope finds that Aaron still has some surprises up his sleeve when it comes to their relationship.Criminal Minds, T, English, Romance, words: 2k+, favs: 14, follows: 9, 12/7/2019, [P. Garcia, A. Hotchner/Hotch]
5 I'll Drink To That by pandorabox82
Penelope finds that settling for someone has a disastrous outcome when she's drugged and left for dead. Will the one person she's been pining after for years come to her rescue, or will it be too late to let him know that she loves him?Criminal Minds, T, English, Drama & Hurt/Comfort, words: 2k+, favs: 22, follows: 10, 10/1/2019, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia
39Before i go to sleep » by eorkjm
after a team member nearly dies will love blossom or will it tear the team apart? and is one of there fellow team mates holding a very large secret? A/UCriminal Minds, T, English, Hurt/Comfort & Romance, chapters: 20, words: 27k+, favs: 49, follows: 67, updated: 9/11/2019 published: 11/15/2015, [A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia] D. Morgan, D. Rossi
41Three Hundred » by sherryola
As the BAU is trying to figure out how to save Reid and Garcia, Rossi calls for reinforcements, bringing in Garcia's secret fiancé and an old friend. What will happen when an enraged Aaron Hotchner races to the scene? My fantasy for episode 300.Criminal Minds, M, English, Suspense & Romance, chapters: 7, words: 12k+, favs: 54, follows: 49, updated: 12/21/2018 published: 9/21/2018, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia, D. Rossi, S. Reid
3Garcia new life » by Fanfics of awesomeness
Garcia one night stand lead her to leaving the team becoming a mom and faking her deathCriminal Minds, K, English, Drama & Crime, chapters: 3, words: 996, favs: 9, follows: 11, updated: 11/11/2018 published: 11/10/2018, Jack H., P. Garcia, L. Alvez, A. Hotchner/Hotch
51 Running scared » by Leigh59
Penelope is on the run, to protect the team and their children how far is she willing to go.Criminal Minds, T, English, Drama, chapters: 5, words: 7k+, favs: 49, follows: 35, updated: 3/10/2018 published: 9/15/2017
120 Somewhere close, somewhere safe » by Leigh59
Having had enough Hotch leaves to start a new life away from the stress and danger. To give peace to his only child. Finding a gift on his desk, he calls a friend only to find out the gift giver has left the BAU as well. One horrific case too many and she finally broke fleeing without leaving a trace of her whereabouts.Criminal Minds, K+, English, Drama & Romance, chapters: 14, words: 22k+, favs: 94, follows: 69, updated: 2/28/2018 published: 11/6/2016
30 Under the Weather » by sherryola
Hotch and Garcia have developed an outside of work friendship. On this Christmas Eve, will Aaron take the chance to let Penelope know how important she is to both him and Jack? Will they find love with each other this Christmas?Criminal Minds, M, English, Romance, chapters: 2, words: 12k+, favs: 66, follows: 29, updated: 1/9/2018 published: 12/30/2017, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia, Jack H.
244Little White Lies » by ReidsKitty
Derek leaving the team breaks Penelope's heart in more ways than one leaving her mourning the lost of her friend. It also leaves her with something that doesn't just go away after time.Criminal Minds, K+, English, Angst & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 23, words: 16k+, favs: 84, follows: 141, updated: 12/17/2017 published: 4/4/2016, A. Hotchner/Hotch, D. Morgan, P. Garcia, Savannah H.
3 The Christmas Of BAU by AnySciuto
a secret friend joke ends up joining a different couple. Hotch and Garcia end up coming home at Christmas.Criminal Minds, K, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 2k+, favs: 6, follows: 4, 12/5/2017, A. Hotchner/Hotch, P. Garcia
4You Don't Know Me » by mystic664
Hotch, and Jack are kidnapped. There is another child there as well. Hotch is forced to choose between having his son hurt, or hurting the other child himself.Criminal Minds, T, English, Crime & Family, chapters: 4, words: 2k+, favs: 10, follows: 16, updated: 10/22/2017 published: 10/17/2017