2k+ Incubus » by Crimson1 The epic tale of the Winchesters teaming up with an incubus who has the hots for Dean, and how he changes their lives forever. Starts after Season 2 finale for an alternate Seasons 3-5. Dean x OMC. Eventual Sam x Sarah Blake.
Supernatural, M, English, Drama & Suspense, chapters: 111, words: 989k+, favs: 738, follows: 384, updated: 11/11/2015 published: 9/23/2007, Dean W., Sam W.
410Reality Check » by NongPradu After a bad hunt, Dean wakes up to find that nothing is as it should be. Rubber rooms and padded walls, with no hope of escape, unless he can convince Sam that he's not crazy.
Supernatural, T, English, Angst, chapters: 18, words: 83k+, favs: 294, follows: 307, updated: 5/8/2009 published: 1/6/2009, Dean W., Sam W.
51A Home of Sorts » by NongPradu Fall of 1996. Sam and Dean are at Harbatkan High School while John goes off on an important hunting mission. Life at first seems normal until the boys notice that people in this town are disappearing. Are they ready to hunt without their dad?
Supernatural, T, English, Mystery, chapters: 8, words: 37k+, favs: 34, follows: 37, updated: 1/25/2009 published: 1/12/2009