160My Super Cute Super Secret Girlfriend » Having grown up in a mafia family with fire magic, you can imagine Natsu's relationship with someone with magic as pure as the stars, was a bit forbidden. Disaster struck when Jude misheard Igneel and Layla talking on her deathbed like they were in love. After Layla's death, Jude turned on Igneel, and plunged into darkness. Thus, My Super Cute Super Secret Girlfiend begins.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Spiritual, chapters: 12, words: 73k+, favs: 192, follows: 268, updated: 10/27/2020 published: 8/30/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
536Blurry Lines » Lucy rejected her desires at first. There is no way she is attracted to her student. But as time went on, it got much harder to deny the blatant way she longed for Natsu. And even worse, it wasn't just a physical and sexual desire, it was emotional. She wanted to be held and comforted by him. So the lines blurred, and blurred, until there was nothing left to deny. It was just them.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 45, words: 188k+, favs: 376, follows: 478, updated: 9/19/2020 published: 9/29/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
286Lost from Heaven » Natsu had this uncontrollable desire to comfort and protect the small, frail girl he met that cold Saturday night. Dressed in fishnets, tight shorts, and high heals, Natsu knew what she was and what she did for a living, but the dead, chocolate brown eyes that stared back at him, only made him more sure with what he had to do. And he fell in love. He fell in love with a prostitute.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Friendship, chapters: 23, words: 97k+, favs: 242, follows: 338, updated: 5/29/2019 published: 10/8/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
39Unconditionally » kidnappers are agreed to be awful. They abduct kids, take them places and harm them. Except Lucy's kidnapper was like her god. He saved her and gave her a home. She never knew why he kidnapped her. Why he had all these photos of her covering his wall. Lucy didn't care though because he was a different kind of kidnapper. Instead of the abuse at home, he loved her. Unconditionally.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Crime & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 3, words: 11k+, favs: 67, follows: 127, updated: 5/20/2019 published: 1/11/2019, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
156Take Flight » Natsu always dreamed he would find his mate, fall in love, and make little dragon babies. The only problem was he had no idea how to find his destined one, until his father told him a little dragons secret. If you write a letter and release it to the wind, it'll fly like dragon wings and find your mate for you. Now only if she knew the truth, then it would truly be a happy ending.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 14, words: 43k+, favs: 207, follows: 348, updated: 3/17/2019 published: 10/29/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
48My Ship Sunk » Lucy just wanted one thing in life; for Natsu and Gray to get together. But things don't turn out as she planned when she tries giving him advice, and he ends up kissing her instead of Gray. Will her OTP become canon or will she come between her favorite ship?
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 4, words: 8k+, favs: 72, follows: 116, updated: 1/16/2019 published: 4/5/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
78Pretty Lies » She knew her 16th birthday would be life changing. And it certainly was, just not in the way Lucy thought it would be. She should have just stayed home with levy like usual. And she regrets going, she regrets starting this game, and she regrets how she hurt him. But it was too late. She would make the worst mistake. Or maybe the best? It wasn't hers to decide, but entirely Natsu's.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 9, words: 37k+, favs: 72, follows: 109, updated: 1/15/2019 published: 12/27/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
59Tainted » It started off as a dream, but quickly grew out of proportion and into something almost unidentifiable. Strange things started to happen, and he noticed the marks she made on him, were no longer just in his dreams. Then one day, she showed up, but it was too late to back out. He was in too deep, and he knew she felt the same way as well. Succubus Au
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Fantasy, chapters: 5, words: 13k+, favs: 101, follows: 167, updated: 6/30/2018 published: 11/27/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
26Poofy Skirts and Ashy Skin » Natsu never thought a bottomless lead to his dad would bring him such joy and happiness in the form of a rich heiress to a railroad tycoon. He stayed in that town till he couldn't any longer and continued to visit her as years passed by. Eventually he couldn't stand seeing her so lonely so he took her back to the pub where he introduced her to the family he made. Victorian magic AU
Fairy Tail, M, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 3, words: 8k+, favs: 49, follows: 93, updated: 4/3/2018 published: 2/11/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]