122Fallen a Mills guide to wooing Brom » by Frostbytefire He was possibly the meanest man in Sleepy Hollow...the world; but that was not going to stop Jenny Mills from trying to make him smile...human by using her sister of course. AU
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 9, words: 35k+, favs: 26, follows: 44, updated: 6/19 published: 1/11/2015
111The Warrior's Bride » by Frostbytefire Forced to marry against his will Abraham Van Brunt decides that he will never touch this woman...then he meets her.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Humor & Romance, chapters: 6, words: 21k+, favs: 50, follows: 69, updated: 2/15 published: 12/3/2016, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Headless Horseman, Caroline
360 Simply Ichabbie » by imAdork26 These are short stories about Ichabod and Abbie's relationship. I hope you will enjoy them as much as I will enjoy writing them. There will be more to come soon. Please feel free to give me some of your ideas. :)
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 69, words: 120k+, favs: 90, follows: 112, updated: 1/16 published: 6/2/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M.
140KnightPhall » by Frostbytefire Sometimes it is best to let sleeping wolves sleep.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Supernatural & Romance, chapters: 7, words: 32k+, favs: 66, follows: 108, updated: 1/11/2018 published: 12/30/2014, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Headless Horseman, N. Hawley
68The Aphrodite Infection » by Frostbytefire The blade of Aphrodite was a powerful weapon against evil but if its blade touched, the lovelorn, unhinged passion would control their life and quicken their death.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Supernatural & Drama, chapters: 5, words: 18k+, favs: 46, follows: 78, updated: 12/17/2017 published: 1/21/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Katrina C., Headless Horseman
65Abigail and the Bad Men » by Frostbytefire Making a deal with Abraham seemed to be a good idea in the beginning until he told her the price for his protection.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Supernatural & Drama, chapters: 5, words: 20k+, favs: 39, follows: 66, updated: 11/22/2017 published: 8/26/2015, Abigail M., Headless Horseman
76The Dark Garden » by Frostbytefire Loneliness and pain can sometimes blur the lines between good and evil.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Romance & Angst, chapters: 4, words: 20k+, favs: 52, follows: 67, updated: 11/7/2017 published: 1/22/2015, Abigail M., A. Brooks, L. Morales, Headless Horseman
27 Cracked, not Broken » by momiji5 Evil loves to play around in the mind's of others.
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Supernatural, chapters: 20, words: 25k+, favs: 18, follows: 26, updated: 7/24/2017 published: 7/17/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Jennifer M., N. Hawley
291781: Crane Manor » by the-bird-howl Abbie gets sent to back 1781 three years into the Witnesses' fight against evil. After finding herself being made a servant in the Crane's humble manor two months before Ichabod's death, Abbie struggles with defeating the demons that plague Rev Era America. FULL SUMMARY INSIDE. Rated M. IchabodxAbbie in later chapters.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Supernatural & Romance, chapters: 7, words: 17k+, favs: 50, follows: 102, updated: 7/15/2017 published: 4/28/2014, [Ichabod C., Abigail M.] Jennifer M., Katrina C.
18Come What May » by KayInSpringtime Years after watching her best friend get married, Abigail Mills comes crashing back into Ichabod Crane's life after a desperate phone call. She has secrets and so does he. Will they be able to work things out together?
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Angst & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 2, words: 3k+, favs: 12, follows: 26, updated: 7/9/2017 published: 3/31/2016, Ichabod C., Abigail M.
232A Will and A Way » by Anomilee1 Where there is a will they will find a way. There is also an inevitable way when you technically don't have an existing choice that's good enough. But that's life. Still they could have done without the extra but in the end they may be glad they didn't have to. Just read it people. Ichabbie is end game. Rated T for now.
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Romance & Angst, chapters: 22, words: 97k+, favs: 61, follows: 104, updated: 5/13/2017 published: 1/30/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Jennifer M., N. Hawley
261I Covet Her » by Frostbytefire A Horseman's wants and desires are not to be ignored.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Drama & Romance, chapters: 10, words: 51k+, favs: 183, follows: 225, updated: 4/7/2017 published: 11/22/2014, [Abigail M., Headless Horseman] Ichabod C.
33Only Make Believe » by Jolo815 SH-AU-Hollywood director Luke Morales casts famous Ichabod Crane for his new major motion picture project. Ichabod is excited by the sweet, romantic script and wants to know who his costar is. He is thrilled to hear it is the new young American actress Abigail Mills who's created a huge buzz in Hollywood. Can both remain friends and professional & tell what is real or make believe?
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 5, words: 17k+, favs: 5, follows: 16, updated: 3/20/2017 published: 11/27/2016, Ichabod C., Abigail M., L. Morales, Katrina C.
43 Revelation » by amy.ward.906 A runaway girl, who has untapped powers finds herself in the custody of Lt. Abigail Mills and Ichabod Crane. What will the future hold for this teenager? Set several years after Season 2 ends.
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Supernatural & Friendship, chapters: 33, words: 28k+, favs: 50, follows: 45, updated: 1/9/2017 published: 5/11/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M., OC
234Winner Takes All » by blackwolfmajik Abraham finds that he's not the only one trapped in a vicious circle of love. Abbie thinks they could find a way out together, but is it all just a ploy by the Horsemen to achieve their End Game? Primarily Brambie, with hints of Ichabbie
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Drama & Romance, chapters: 18, words: 57k+, favs: 130, follows: 163, updated: 9/14/2016 published: 4/9/2015, Ichabod C., Abigail M., Jennifer M., Headless Horseman
47One Shots - Ichabbie » by MagicInHerMadness Ichabbie one shots. Usually AU. Rated M for later works.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 6, words: 10k+, favs: 29, follows: 31, updated: 8/1/2016 published: 10/23/2015, Abigail M., Ichabod C.
12 As Long As It Takes » by opalheart12 Abbie Mills didn't die. Ichabod and Jenny were able to get her back. The 'how' of it wasn't important. Pandora was gone, as was the Headless Horseman for the time being. For the moment, all was well. Except it wasn't.
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Drama & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 6, words: 12k+, favs: 15, follows: 18, updated: 7/21/2016 published: 5/20/2016
197 The Last Rose » by sneetchstar Beauty and the Beast Ichabbie AU fairy tale.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Drama & Romance, chapters: 13, words: 39k+, favs: 85, follows: 78, updated: 6/22/2016 published: 4/5/2016, Ichabod C., Abigail M.
4Sacrifice » by FitzgLivviep Abby did what she thought was right and would do it again in a heartbeat if it meant protecting those she loved by doing that she found her true calling in her sacrifice.
Sleepy Hollow, T, English, Supernatural & Romance, chapters: 2, words: 2k+, favs: 4, follows: 9, updated: 4/8/2016 published: 2/5/2016
15Unexpected » by kmariah369 Unexpected relationship between sleepy hollow characters.
Sleepy Hollow, M, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 2, words: 4k+, favs: 19, follows: 23, updated: 4/4/2016 published: 3/28/2016, [Abigail M., Headless Horseman] [Ichabod C., Katrina C.]