445What I Want? » by YukiMC The life of an old money heir isn't as great as it seems. From the outside she had everything, money, fame, popularity, clothes-everything a girl could want...and then it was gone. Just like that, Lucy finds herself living a lie with this short tempered man who now owns her, mind, body, and soul, losing it all as she questions what she really wants.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 26, words: 178k+, favs: 515, follows: 661, updated: 7/26 published: 6/13/2015, Lucy H., Natsu D., E.N.D.
444Request Board Romance » by MorriganFae Lucy and Levy are new to Fairy Tail. Having spent most of their lives at the all-girls guild, Mermaid Heel, the two are ready to explore their magic, friendship and maybe even dating. Forging friendships comes easy, but romance? Ha. Forget about it. Until one day, Lucy sees her picture on the request board. The mission? A date with Lucy. The reward? True love. A/U.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 24, words: 144k+, favs: 327, follows: 519, updated: 7/12 published: 1/13/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.] [Levy M., Gajeel R.]
1k+How to Seduce a Lady » by Aky-san What do you get when you clash an arrogant playboy and the girl the whole school makes fun of? Prince Hot and Bothered and shy servant? Watch Natsu seduce his way to happiness... or not. / Modern School AU / Natsu & Lucy / originally a oneshot / rated T for EXPLICIT SCENES
Fairy Tail, T, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 26, words: 134k+, favs: 642, follows: 778, updated: 7/12 published: 3/4/2017, [Natsu D., Lucy H.] [Gray F., Juvia L.]
359Fairies and Dragons » by ottermadness Lucy was supposed to be out shopping, buying a birthday present for a friend. She didn't expect to be roped into a game of Dungeons and Dragons when she entered a tabletop store out of mild curiosity. Modern AU. Eventual NaLu with other minor pairings.
Fairy Tail, T, English, Friendship & Romance, chapters: 29, words: 228k+, favs: 259, follows: 309, updated: 7/7 published: 7/26/2020, [Lucy H., Natsu D.] Erza S., Gray F.
939Talking Body » by Don't Touch Me I'm Feeling AU: "Yes he said it. He was a male stripper and a male phone sex operator. Yes she said it. She was a teacher." Hanging out with Cana always led to something, and this time it happened to be a male strip club. There were times when Lucy questioned what she was doing with her life. Rated M for everything not T, including male stripping.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Humor, chapters: 25, words: 84k+, favs: 805, follows: 1k+, updated: 4/24 published: 8/18/2015, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
4k+Capturing Her Damaged Heart » by mushi9 A deadly disease plagues the world. People are dying, the dead are rising. The infection spreads too fast to stop. Everyone tries their best to survive in this post-apocalyptic world, but things get messy for Natsu when he finds a blonde woman on one of his missions. Natsu takes it upon himself to help her, protect her, and accidentally fall in love with her? Zombie Apocalypse AU.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Hurt/Comfort & Romance, chapters: 82, words: 716k+, favs: 1k+, follows: 1k+, updated: 2/12 published: 4/6/2017, [Natsu D., Lucy H.] Erza S., Gray F.
55Chasing Stars » by eliegloryofficial Once a world-renowned musician, Lucy Heartfilia put her violin away for the last time when she was seventeen. Five years later, she finds herself drawn back into the world of music after meeting a pianist with a fiery style of playing.
Fairy Tail, T, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 5, words: 21k+, favs: 93, follows: 141, updated: 10/28/2021 published: 2/26/2018, [Natsu D., Lucy H.]
2k+Passive Aggressive Post-Its » by quite-a-riot When a fateful encounter results in Lucy being linked to a complete stranger, she will have to find a way to live with (and maybe just love) the messy scribbler who seemingly shares her skin. Lucy can't help resisting the pull of fate, but when friends get involved, she doesn't stand a chance. Set where Earth meets Earthland, being a college freshman has never been quite like this.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Humor & Romance, chapters: 58, words: 569k+, favs: 932, follows: 1k+, updated: 10/13/2021 published: 3/21/2017, [Lucy H., Natsu D.] [Levy M., Gajeel R.]
192Like This Video » by VintagePoison Lucy's an anime-based YouTuber with a massively growing fanbase, who just so happens to be crushing on a certain member of the even bigger anime-based channel, Fairy Tail. She's never met him, and isn't planning to any time soon, but she will soon learn that plans change and life beyond her apartment in the small town of Hargeon is about to get crazy. Nalu.
Fairy Tail, T, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 9, words: 39k+, favs: 235, follows: 344, updated: 9/26/2021 published: 3/4/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.] Erza S., Gray F.
977 To the Flame » by AbsentAngel She stares, transfixed, as the blood runs down his fingers and begins to pool in his palm. He holds his hand up to her lips in offering, and she tears her eyes away from the blood to study his face. He is smiling softly. "Go on Luce, I didn't cut them for nothing." [Vamp AU] [NaLu]
Fairy Tail, T, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 19, words: 62k+, favs: 1k+, follows: 1k+, updated: 4/1/2021 published: 9/25/2014, Lucy H., Natsu D.
190If The Shoe Fits » by MorriganFae Fairy Tail story with a Cinderella twist. Lucy is tired of being a slave to her step-mother and step-sisters, who mockingly call her "Cinderella" because she can't feel heat—not from the sun or hearth or boiling water. Then one day she meets the Prince and learns that fire comes in all sorts of different forms. Rated M. Nalu. This story is a gift for my good friend, Satyrykal.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Fantasy, chapters: 5, words: 24k+, favs: 277, follows: 396, updated: 11/30/2020 published: 3/2/2018, Lucy H., Natsu D.
544What's a Witch » by Mslead-Kytrin Lucy had an average but happy life. She didn't ask to get dragged into a multi-dimensional war with a happy-go-lucky Demon King. One who couldn't eat a bowl of oatmeal without splattering it on his face. Still, until she figured out a way to break the spell binding them together, Lucy guessed she was stuck with him. NALU.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Supernatural & Romance, chapters: 21, words: 102k+, favs: 1k+, follows: 1k+, updated: 10/19/2020 published: 3/30/2015, Gajeel R., Levy M., Lucy H., Natsu D.
811The Prince of Pergrande » by SiahTai "I am free no matter what rules surround me. If I find them tolerable, I will tolerate them. Should I find them bothersome, I will break them. I was born free, I have lived my life free, and I will remain free until the day I die."
Fairy Tail, T, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 4, words: 29k+, favs: 1k+, follows: 1k+, updated: 9/21/2020 published: 12/28/2013, [Lucy H., Natsu D.]
307Glory and Gore » by stopnatsu He's cold, he's ruthless, he's a killer. It's in his blood. He's a member of the brotherhood, Fiore's most dangerous gang, and he's ready for a fight. Lucy is a journalist in the wrong place at the wrong time. Maybe she makes him more human. But victory is contagious, and Natsu is playing a dangerous game. *I AM EDITING/REWORKING THIS PIECE SUMMER 2020, CHECK BACK FOR CHANGES!
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Crime, chapters: 4, words: 12k+, favs: 275, follows: 369, updated: 8/16/2020 published: 7/22/2018, Gajeel R., Lucy H., Natsu D.
84 crash & burn » by splendidlyimperfect When Gray's therapist makes him attend a program for troubled youth, he's not impressed. Then he meets Natsu, a charismatic boy with pink hair and piercings who's larger than life, and Gray starts to fall in love. But when the dark parts of Natsu's past start to catch up with him, it's up to Gray to try and pick up the pieces.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Hurt/Comfort & Angst, chapters: 33, words: 98k+, favs: 143, follows: 92, updated: 11/8/2019 published: 11/10/2017, [Gray F., Natsu D.] [Freed J., Laxus D.]
4k+Berserk » by Rivendell101 Berserk. Out of control with anger. This is what Natsu was born to be. A warrior soaked in blood. A murderer. This is what Pergrande turned him into. Taken at a young age by the King, Natsu is a soldier of the Royal Army, a creature of rage and violence—a weapon. Lucy is a thief from Fiore with a price on her head and magic in her blood.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 48, words: 238k+, favs: 1k+, follows: 1k+, updated: 3/1/2019 published: 2/3/2017, [Natsu D., Lucy H.] Jellal F./Siegrain, Laxus D.
243The Edge » by Satyrykal For as long as Lucy can remember, she had been warned about the Others who lived beyond the Edge. Dark and fearsome creatures, the Others are able to enthrall anyone foolish enough to approach them. Then one night, when such a man is dragged beaten and bloodied before her, she can't help but forgo the warnings. Dark Fantasy AU based on Beauty & the Beast. For MorriganFae's B-day!
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Fantasy, chapters: 4, words: 19k+, favs: 351, follows: 506, updated: 2/16/2019 published: 3/1/2018, [Natsu D., Lucy H.] E.N.D.
1k+ Open Marriage » by mushi9 Lucy has the best of both worlds: A cool, collected, loving husband and a fiery, passionate boyfriend. She's not having an affair. She and her husband, Gray, have an agreement. As long as everyone follows the rules, things will go smoothly. However, they didn't realize how much they would both want to bend the rules until they met Natsu. Gratsulu is endgame. Modern AU.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Romance & Friendship, chapters: 41, words: 299k+, favs: 421, follows: 409, updated: 1/9/2019 published: 1/3/2018, [Natsu D., Lucy H., Gray F.]
157 Spread Your Wings » by noseinabook145 A series of unfortunate (or fortunate?) events leads to Lucy taking an offer to travel Fiore on a secret mission. She'll save lives, grow her skills...but will have to leave Natsu, with whom things are starting to heat up, behind. She swears to return, stronger than ever, but can she survive her adventures to face a hidden danger at home? NaLu
Fairy Tail, M, English, Adventure & Romance, chapters: 14, words: 67k+, favs: 264, follows: 169, updated: 9/29/2018 published: 5/14/2018, [Lucy H., Natsu D.] Lisanna S.
129Scintilla » by zhime Familiars. Shields. Weapons. Coveted and controlled. Used by witches to maintain status and power, or be forced to fight for their lives. But then he's found by her—by golden hair and dark gold eyes and warmth he's never known. And she's in more trouble than she can admit. Witch/Familiar!AU. NaLu. Rated for violence, injury, torture.
Fairy Tail, M, English, Fantasy & Hurt/Comfort, chapters: 4, words: 47k+, favs: 192, follows: 248, updated: 9/3/2018 published: 12/13/2017, Gray F., Lucy H., Natsu D.